Who's Your Pick for the Heisman?

I'd go with Tebow...but I dont think he'll get it.

 

Other: Karl Kold.

 

Tebow should get it, but I think McFadden will.

 

Chase Daniel or D-Mac. Tebow close behind.

 

Anybody but Tebow.

 

I voted Dixon who is clearly the most important player in CFB. In injury he has proven how vital he was to Oregon. Its a no brainer IMO. But the tradionalists will give it to an uperclassmen on a good team who played in all the games. The same traditionalists that will have USC ranked #1 next season, the ones that will keep an undefeated Auburn team out of the NC game, the same guys that wouldn't let Mike Williams play his senior year...

 

Michael Crabtree.

Look at those #s

 

Tebow should win the Heisman. He has been the best player in College Football from start to finish. If he wasn't a Sophmore this would not even be a discussion.

 

Look at that system.

If you're gonna say look at the numbers than Colt Brennan wins the Heisman last year easily with 58 touchdown passes.

 

If he wins this weekend, should be Chase without question. Don't think it will be, but it should. A quarterback with those kinds of numbers and skills taking Missouri to #1 and the brink of a national title... ridiculous.

The Tebow and McFadden love is a little irritating. For years, the best overall players (Fitzgerald, VY, Grossman, etc.) have lost out to the logic of quarterbacks/running backs that lead their team to wins and a No. 1 ranking in addition to posting quality numbers. I'm not saying that's necessarily how it should be, but that's how it's been.

Sucks that the "winner" mentality among voters and fans only applies if the quarterback plays for a top-shelf program in terms of prestige.

 

I hate Florida more than I do Tennessee, Oklahoma, Penn State, and Alabama combined. Probably only Ohio State and Notre Dame are 2 schools that I despise more than the Gators.

Yet, I can't see anyone other than Tebow winning the Heisman. Personally, I would love to see McFadden or Daniel or hell anyone OTHER than Tebow win it, but I don't think it is going to happen.

 

tebow is gonna win by a larger than expected margin.

 

while i somewhat think he'll win by a larger than expected margin also, it's kinda weird how much of a anybody but tebow sentiment there seems to be (i guess b/c that's how i feel and i'm usually going against the tide). he actually didn't win the walter camp award (which has matched up with the heisman 21 of the last 25 times while the maxwell hasn't won the heisman 7 straight), he barely won the espn fan poll (35.0% to 34.3%) and now he's losing here. while i feel like i'm being disingenuous by not voting for him and just doing it b/c i don't like him, i do kinda think mcfadden really is the best player. he was considered the best coming into the season and it would be hard to say he hasn't lived up to the hype.

what's really amazing is how many unwritten rules tebow winning will break. usually you have to be on a top team, while florida has 3 losses. i think they sad only a few heisman's ever have come from teams with more than 2 losses. you usually can't be a system guy. now since he plays at a big school and the system splits the ridiculous TD numbers b/t passing and rushing instead of just all passing like hawaii, it doesn't hurt him as much. and the most importantly, the no underclassmen rule. no sophomore or freshman has ever won it. and the first one to win it is going to be a system guy for a 3 loss team? what a weird freakin' year. here's hoping for a miracle and a mcfadden win, but i don't see it. maybe the voters are more entrenched when it comes to all the unwritten rules than i think.

 

Captain SouthLake

 

The best player this season was Tim Tebow. He should and will probably win the Heisman. I have not heard an arguement against him that would sway me.

McFadden is great. Had a few off games. Tebow did not.

Brannan did not play anybody. Great passer that put up big numbers against the WAC. Tebow put up similar numbers in the SEC and is one tough S.O.B.

 

I want Colt Brennan to win. Tebow is overrated. McFadden is legit.

 

tebow will win because he is a cracker that white people love to root for. he's a goofy looking guy that will try to hype the crowd up with his random bs, but in the end he wears jorts and birkenstock sandals, that's a big part of why he will win the heisman.