1. Welcome! Please take a few seconds to create your free account to post threads, make some friends, remove a few ads while surfing and much more. ClutchFans has been bringing fans together to talk Houston Sports since 1996. Join us!

What do you think is the purpose of life/ what keeps you going?

Discussion in 'BBS Hangout: Debate & Discussion' started by crazyguypete, Sep 12, 2007.

  1. Extraordinary_2

    Joined:
    Jun 21, 2007
    Messages:
    94
    Likes Received:
    0
    Thomas Edison basically said that God is the worst invention in the history of the planet. God didn't invent light bulb for us, he did, so to me, Edison is God.

    God is the worst thing people invented.
     
  2. right1

    right1 Member

    Joined:
    Feb 9, 2002
    Messages:
    2,505
    Likes Received:
    1,135
    http://www.hyperhistory.net/apwh/bios/b4edisont.htm
    Unfortunately, Thomas had a slight hearing disability, which worsened year by year.

    "I do not believe in the God of the theologians; but that there is a Supreme Intelligence I do not doubt."

    "My mind is incapable of conceiving such a thing as a soul. I may be in error..."

    Have fun with your Ouija board!
     
  3. rhester

    rhester Member

    Joined:
    Jun 14, 2001
    Messages:
    6,600
    Likes Received:
    104
    A 'human' coping mechanism is a way of dealing with issues by our efforts.

    Divine salvation is God's way of dealing with issues we cannot by our effort.

    When you look for God and you can't find Him that doesn't mean He doesn't exist, it just means your search is flawed or your direction is off.

    God is a spirit. He sent Jesus in human flesh to make Himself observable.
    What else should He do for the logical mind?

    If Jesus doesn't satisfy reason, nothing will.

    If God has done His best to reveal Himself and you refuse Him, whose fault is it?

    Jesus Christ is the revelation of God to man.

    These things are hidden from the wise and they are revealed to children.
     
  4. crazyguypete

    crazyguypete Member

    Joined:
    Aug 7, 2002
    Messages:
    179
    Likes Received:
    5
    I haven't had a chance to post till now but I have been reading through this thread over the weekend and its interesting to see how this thread has branched off to be as much about purpose of life as issues of self and consciousness and awareness. In any case, I think I need to make some comments first not only to defend my stance but also to try and show some, what I thus far see as, fallacies in what others.

    My stance thus far has been the most important attribute we can have and look for is knowledge. It may not be THE purpose of life, but its the best we can logically deduce. First, I think what is necessary is to define knowledge as I see it. The dictionary defines knowledge as, "acquaintance with facts, truths, or principles." Thus if we acquire facts, truths, and principles we can make an educated decision about what we should do with our lives. The argument against this is that well if all we do is get knowledge would we not do "immoral" acts to achieve these goals. Well, if you studied certain facts, truths, and principles you would realize and deduce that those "immoral" acts are "immoral" and thus would not be good for you to do. They would not be in your best interest after all.

    Another issue that has been stated concerns miracles. To the religious person miracles are critical because their religious text cite them and contend that it illustrates God's power. But are miracles even possible? Again we have to define what a miracle is. According to the dictionary, miracles are, "Events that appear inexplicable by the laws of nature and so are held to be supernatural in origin or an act of God." Now I am assuming that the laws of nature are the most educated rules deduced from years of scientific and philosophical inquires that explain phenomena. What I think is a critical point here is to establish what we know vs what can be done. We may see something as miraculous when in fact over time it can be explained. In this light miracles are really nothing more than human ignorance. However, if we contend that our world works under certain rules and a God can come into this world and take whatever those rules are and defy them and thats what a miracle is then I have to say thats not possible logically. Why? Because a set cannot have any elements in it other then the elements it has in it. If everything in that set has to adhere to certain principles and something doesn't then its not what it was. Thus, if we have defined never changing rules nothing can change it b/c if it does its a logical contradiction.

    This can be extended to a certain problem with God in the hierarchy of everything. God is suppose to be at the top of everything under most people's idea of what God is. But, as stated earlier, morality can exist independent of God and in fact a God would have to adhere to the morality not the other way around. In other words, God does not make something good, it is good because it is good.

    Furthermore, and to me an even stronger point along these lines, is that God is not higher than logic. Now when I say logic I don't mean man's logic, I mean logic period. There is no way of achieving any meaning without certain logical principles. If you try and do that everything will lack meaning. This is why post modernism does not work. It tries to define everything as undefinable which is in and of itself a contradiction. These are innate fundamental rules, there are no way around them. These rules are so grand that even the Religious God has to follow them. Thus, there is something higher than God. Logic is higher than even God, unless of course thats what God is ;) .

    By the way Mr. Meowgi I find your posts to be the ones i most agree and disagree with. You are going to end up making Amazon.com rich as can be and me poor as can be. I don't think I completely understand what you are saying but at one point you mentioned all things are in flux. Well, I can't see ALL things as in flux. That to me is relativism and relativism does not work because to say everything is relative is an absolute statement. I'll contend that there are things in flux, but not ALL things.

    Mr. Meowgi you and others also commented on being happy and thats what everyone really wants. Well I'll be the first to say to hell with happiness. I don't want happy I want the truth. I want to understand whats going on b/c I think thats what is best, even at the sacrifice of happiness (which according to the dictionary is defined as, "a state of well-being characterized by emotions ranging from contentment to intense joy"). Damn my emotions if it is going to lead to greater understanding of everything. In fact, I find myself trying to make myself happy only to better understand things (You start digging deep enough and this stuff gets real depressing, real fast (I think more associated with the death of your old beliefs then anything else) and you need burst of happy to keep looking otherwise the barrel of the gun starts to look like the best option). Not the other way around. I think happiness plays a part but it is not the highest part. There are things bigger than happiness.

    Another stance the religious take is pride. This is C.S. Lewis' BIG thing. Pride is our biggest flaw. However, You need pride to survive and in fact you last in what you do b/c of your pride. When you sit in that tough class, and get through it you get through it b/c of pride. B/c you say I am getting through this class b/c this is who i am. Pride. When you get up everyday and go to your job even though you may not want to, its b/c of pride. Its b/c you define yourself as a person who will not only look after themselves but there loved ones. These most people would contend are good qualities to have but are heavily driven by pride. Pride can cause terrible things but it is necessary. Without it you will give up to any and all challenges.

    Also a note on pride and how its important to be humble. Nothing humbles you more than knowledge. When I dip into these philosophical inquires of mine, like after reading some of these posts I realized just to what degree I am ignorant (in the process of which is actually making me less ignorant.).

    I want to make one last point here and this is what will probably tick people off the most and that is in correlation to all these people who quote the Bible as if its words will show the light to God. First off, isn't there a little bit of biasism in that? Don't you think the best way to get an accurate account of a situation is to examine from an unbiased source?

    But more then that there are things in the Bible that make you lift your eyebrow and say WTF? So I am going to list a couple of them.

    The first comes from Numbers 31:18. In the book God incites Moses to attack the Midianites. Moses does so and is victorious. And with this victory his army slays all the men, burns down the city, BUT they save the women and children. Moses gets infuriated with this and orders that all the boys should be killed and all the women who were not virgins to be killed as well. Quoting now it says, "But all the women children, that have not known a man by lying with him, keep alive for yourselves." Is this right? Is it ok to murder innocent children? And what about the fixation with virgins? The only reason we shouldn't kill someone is b/c they haven't had sex? Thats ok? And do you really think that the women who aren't killed the soldiers are going to take and ask will you please have sex with me? No! They are most likely going to rape. I don't even believe in morals but man come on thats messed up! I do however love the fact that they describe sex as getting to know the person.

    Oh and lets not forget Leviticus 20 that says the death penalty is allowed if you curse your parents, commit adultery, homosexuality, bestiality (the animal has to be killed as well), and working on the sabbath. Are these "good" rules?

    And the last I will state comes from Exodus 20. For those that don't know this is where the ten commandments are. The first commandment, "I am the Lord your God, who brought you out of the land of Egypt, out of the house of slavery; you shall have no other gods before me" is one that many religious people will say is the greatest commandment and breaking it the greatest sin. If you don't believe me google, "greatest sin". In Exodus 32 he goes through and shows you just what will happen to you if you look for another God.

    Now this to me goes against what I consider the best we can do which is get knowledge. Why? Because, if I start inquiring about more then God, if I search for more, if I doubt, he is going to kick the crap out of me. Thats what that chapters says to me. Worse, it instills fear and it has been shown that fear turns off your logic. Does God want us to be illogical beings that follow Him. Truth is, many of you (those that say it doesn't make sense but I still have faith) seem to follow just that.

    Also, is it really fair to those children who are brought up under different faiths (and never will have any opportunity to learn about another faith, which is especially true if their religion says the same thing as a Christian one does). If what I read is to be taken literally, God basically puts people on this earth in faiths that he is saying isn't his and thus damns them to hell. Thats pretty bizarre if you ask me.

    Do i hate the bible? No. These are just a couple of peculiarities I found in my research that made me really say WTF. But the bible does have much good in it. Most of the principles I will agree with. (Notice all my examples are from the Old Testament) Thats not the point. The point is, if Christianity is legit all of it has to be true. If one grain of it is false, its all false. A God can still exist, but its going to be hard to convince me its a Christian one.
     
  5. plutoblue11

    plutoblue11 Member

    Joined:
    Dec 13, 2006
    Messages:
    10,528
    Likes Received:
    1,011
    I believe alot about what your saying....but reality is kinda of vague concepty or entity. Reality does encompass day-to-day events, like most of us go to work (or school), have families, watch or read the news in some way shape form, get married, have kids, go to church (or mosque, synagogue, or temple), then we die and go to heaven or one of the other places. To most that is (our) reality in the nut-shell (in America and similar societies. We understand or reality in the most simplest forms, but not the most complex.

    We can't see everything that's happening in the world or the universe. We can't really see what's happening on far away. We can even see what's happening on our jobs, homes, or etc....like for example...you see when people are totally shock when the someone reveals a secret to them about something work-related, in romantic relationship, or something else about them that they didn't know.

    The reality of people consistently changes, while the world's and universe's
    does not. The world and universe is pretty much has the same basic cycle or order of things through. Also, our reality is sort of constructed by society...like most things...if they prove true is always up for debate.

    To prove God exist to unbeliever could prove difficult, because he has not grasp that possible concept of spirtuality or the presence of omnipotent master and does understand the laws or a requirements.....while unbeliever would have that same difficulty trying to covince a person with a world of faith that this whole God thing is just figment of people's imagination, or socially constructed tool thats has been used to order people's moral character for centuries. It would be monumental for both sides...almost in death or reincarnation as a spirit, angel, or force that could come back to the unbeliever and say "I told you so," or the unbeliever and the believer both die and never heard from again in any form or fashion.

    It's kinda like the "World will never end, but it will end as you know it." Even you die or every other person on this planet is killed after big blast or plague. The world technically will not end, God would not be dead, the Universe will still have the cosmos, but the human race would be ended for that moment in time or possibly forever.
     
  6. plutoblue11

    plutoblue11 Member

    Joined:
    Dec 13, 2006
    Messages:
    10,528
    Likes Received:
    1,011
    I believe alot about what your saying....but reality is kinda of vague concepty or entity. Reality does encompass day-to-day events, like most of us go to work (or school), have families, watch or read the news in some way shape form, get married, have kids, go to church (or mosque, synagogue, or temple), then we die and go to heaven or one of the other places. To most that is (our) reality in the nut-shell (in America and similar societies. We understand or reality in the most simplest forms, but not the most complex.

    We can't see everything that's happening in the world or the universe. We can't really see what's happening on far away. We can even see what's happening on our jobs, homes, or etc....like for example...you see when people are totally shock when the someone reveals a secret to them about something work-related, in romantic relationship, or something else about them that they didn't know.

    The reality of people consistently changes, while the world's and universe's
    does not. The world and universe is pretty much has the same basic cycle or order of things through. Also, our reality is sort of constructed by society...like most things...if they prove true is always up for debate.

    To prove God exist to unbeliever could prove difficult, because he has not grasp that possible concept of spirtuality or the presence of omnipotent master and does understand the laws or a requirements.....while unbeliever would have that same difficulty trying to covince a person with a world of faith that this whole God thing is just figment of people's imagination, or socially constructed tool thats has been used to order people's moral character for centuries. It would be monumental for both sides...almost in death or reincarnation as a spirit, angel, or force that could come back to the unbeliever and say "I told you so," or the unbeliever and the believer both die and never heard from again in any form or fashion.

    It's kinda like the "World will never end, but it will end as you know it." Even you die or every other person on this planet is killed after big blast or plague. The world technically will not end, God would not be dead, the Universe will still have the cosmos, but the human race would be ended for that moment in time or possibly forever.
     
  7. Invisible Fan

    Invisible Fan Member

    Joined:
    Dec 5, 2001
    Messages:
    45,954
    Likes Received:
    28,049
    You start off saying to hell with happiness and then say happiness plays a big part. Not many people are happy a majority of their lives. Religious people sometimes sacrifice immediate happiness for the sake of their religion. If knowledge alone makes you happy, then go for it.

    Every now and then you make these statements that sound Christian like. I get the feeling you want God to prove himself to you through various challenges. It rarely works out like that. You're relativistic yet you want to believe in Absolute Truth (albeit in the form of Knowledge). Perhaps you want that Absolute Truth to be practiced upon others so their lives can be bettered by the Discovery.

    Without the human race, who will be there to worship God?

    In a sense, knowing the existence of intelligent aliens would make the question simpler, but it would knock against that claim that we or they are the Chosen Race of our Creator.
     
    #127 Invisible Fan, Sep 18, 2007
    Last edited: Sep 18, 2007
  8. crazyguypete

    crazyguypete Member

    Joined:
    Aug 7, 2002
    Messages:
    179
    Likes Received:
    5
     
  9. MadMax

    MadMax Member

    Joined:
    Sep 19, 1999
    Messages:
    76,683
    Likes Received:
    25,924

    I feel the same way you do about the Bible. It freaks me out at times. There's stuff in there that I wish wasn't Certainly lots of stuff in there I don't get...and so much we miss because of historical context.

    But I don't understand the point about of "if one grain of it is false, it's all false." What do you mean? You have to be a complete literalist, or there was no resurrection?? Job can't be a parable? Genesis is a poem...does it have to be 100% factually true to communicate truth? Can it not just communicate that there was a Creator who created creation? I'm with you on the Gospel accounts...but those are presented differently. Luke starts by saying, "i'm making an account of these things that happened." That's a whole different tone though than most of the Bible.

    You're aware, I assume...that the Bible is a collection of different books and letters written by various different writers over the course of thousands of years, right?

    Book suggestion: "Velvet Elvis" by Rob Bell.
     
    #129 MadMax, Sep 18, 2007
    Last edited: Sep 18, 2007
  10. right1

    right1 Member

    Joined:
    Feb 9, 2002
    Messages:
    2,505
    Likes Received:
    1,135
    How is Genesis a poem? Isn't it a historical account of the Hebrew people through Abraham, Isaac and Jacob Israel whose descendents are the twelve tribes of Israel? About how Jacob's son Joseph became prime minister of Egypt and answered only to pharaoh? And about how a famine in the land caused the Israelites to go to Egypt to buy grain in order to survive?
     
  11. MadMax

    MadMax Member

    Joined:
    Sep 19, 1999
    Messages:
    76,683
    Likes Received:
    25,924
    sorry..the first chapter or so is a poem. too often i use the word "genesis" as a synonym for the creation story.
     
  12. rhester

    rhester Member

    Joined:
    Jun 14, 2001
    Messages:
    6,600
    Likes Received:
    104
    What good is knowledge if it is mis applied or incorrect or worse yet not used rightly, if at all? How does knowledge affect divorce, crime and war? What about child abuse and greed? Ignorance can be blamed for many things when in fact it rarely is actually a problem. Moral actions require knowledge. Realizing something is immoral has no bearing on actions taken. The basis of moral decisions is love, whether something is selfish or benevolent, not knowledge.

    Here is one example that proves this- let's say that you found an absolute foolproof way to hack into the government treasury and transfer up to 1 billion dollars into a secure account in your name in Switzerland. You have the knowledge that the government annually writes off several billion dollars in unexplained loss. You are guaranteed never to be caught. No one will ever miss it or know about it. You alone have this knowledge and opportunity.

    Your facts, truths and principles tell you that since no one will miss it, no one will suffer for it, and no one will ever even know about it you will not be punished for this.

    Now, what are you going to do with knowledge. Here is where the moral choice must be made. Is it right for you to steal what belongs to someone else? That is a moral choice- right or wrong

    Now if I asked you if you loved the people who rightfully made those deposits
    as much as you loved yourself (the Golden Rule) I could tell the truth by the choice you made. If you stole from them, then you cannot say you love them.

    You would be upset if someone stole your car and all your credit cards, yet given the chance to get away with the same thing you might do it.

    I think love is a much better reason for life than knowledge.

    I am a Christian but I don't think of miracles as critical, I consider truth critical.

    But miracles are not a contradiction to logic. It is logical that a powerful God can defy physical laws. Yes, Jesus walked on top of the water, defying physics, he also turned plain water into fine wine (with alcohol I believe) and he fed over five thousand people with a sack lunch. :D


    Correct something is right because it is right, it is good because it is good.

    I think you are really considering the correct things here. It is just as you say except that God is the giver of logic. The logical rule is a description of the logical God. Thus His logic is higher than man's logic.

    This is a good attitude, I am praying for you to find truth. It is far more valuable than happiness.

    I think you might not be thinking of pride and humility as I would anyways.
    Pride is exalting myself higher than I should.
    Humility is seeing my own value in true relation to the value of others and God. The drive to succeed could make you a cheater or a liar. Looking after others is the opposite of pride. Pride makes you more important, results in selfishness and causes you to think you are better than others. Just because you do your best does not make you prideful. It is when you think you can do less than your best that you become prideful.


    This doesn't tick me off at all, You are a very honest poster and I respect everything you have given. After all we only are posting our opinions and we can respect that, right. So I will comment on these verses-


    I would like to point out that God chose to work with these people, and he showed their faults also. God did not direct Moses to keep the virgins for themselves. The other difficulty here is the judgment God took on the Midianites this is an issue that takes quite of bit of understanding of mankind's sin and the justice, judgment and mercy of God. If you care to email me I will give you an answer concerning this that your can read or delete. :) I am not trying to say I understand everything in the Bible either, I am trying to say that without understanding God's redeeming purposes some of this makes no sense at all.

    Again it would take a while to explain what I understand here, my opinion. But you can answer this for yourself, just commit bestiality, homosexuality, adultery and curse your parents and over time you will know if it is good or not. In fact if we all would do all of these things we could know alot sooner if they are indeed logically right, loving and just.

    God is logical if you think on a relational level, instead purely materialistic.
    God's point I think is don't worship what is not a god, what is false. That is logical also. It is good you are inquiring about God, He rewards this.

    The only thing to fear is evil, both in yourself and others.

    I don't think you should blame God for man's attempts at religion. I believe man has messed up religion to the point God is sick of it. God did not put any child here on earth except for the purpose of knowing Him. Christians are at fault for making God religious and keeping children around the world in the dark, let God work this out, He is just, faithful and in eternity all will be right.

    The Bible is the story of Jesus Christ. I really believe He is the one you seek.

    Read the gospel books, Matthew Mark Luke John, in there you will find the Answer. He is a person, God's Son.

    I appreciate your honest comments and questions.
     
  13. Invisible Fan

    Invisible Fan Member

    Joined:
    Dec 5, 2001
    Messages:
    45,954
    Likes Received:
    28,049
    My bad, I mistook someone else's post for yours. However, one truth of our existence is that we change from birth to death. That state of flux is constant or even cyclical under your definition (but not cyclical to you or me). Furthermore, you will constantly set yourself up to change in your pursuit of knowledge. Cast it off as ignorance, but have been changed by what you just read.

    While you can anchor yourself to a few Absolute truths, how you approach the truth in mindset and practice will definitely change as you move further.
     

Share This Page