This may beo ne of the only times we completely agree on something. I think Cutler is overhyped (he may be good) but he isn't Leinart or Young. Even though it's funny to see in your sig how do you know for certain that i have never slept with your wife
I don't question his skills, just his arm strength, I agree he was a great college qb, and he did play a great second half in the Rose Bowl. but I've always questioned his arm, at least since last season.
Just to play devils advocate (and I think Leinart will be good), he did have the best offensive line and the best wide receivers in the game. The few times I have seen him been hit hard and the rush was getting to him (1st half of the Texas game, some of the ASU game, didn't see all the Cal games but possible) he didn't look great, or even good. Leinart has had advantagous no other college QB in recent memory has had, is a he a great player or great bus driver, I suspect the reality is in between. I'd take VY first unless Leinart's arm looks exceptional at the pro day.