Tracy or Yao?

to be honest i would rather have yao, stevie and cuttino!

 

Where's the option for neither?

I have nothing against either of them but they haven't proven they can lead a championship contending team.

 

I'd have to go with Mac...but this thread is encouraging violence...

 

My thoughts exactly. I'm amazed it has lasted this long without any ranting.

 

I can't see what was wrong with Both besides competing with nagging injuries other then that they just needed relief and motivation because positive energy is required to keep your relief fresh and determined and after Jeff they really were short handed untill relief filled in, now it's just the matter of conditioning and health.

 

YOFs ftl. yao, at his peak, was very good, 25/9. If he stayed like that for more than one year, which he didnt and never will, then i'd probably pick yao since it's easier to pick up wings. but yao is made of glass and easily taken out of games with fronting. so i chose tmac, 2 time scoring champion, great court vision, and solid rebounder/assist/steals for his position (for way more years than yao at his peak). whether or not his style of play is conducive to winning, that's another debate. i think it's just a matter of finding the right players

 

I take McGrady's peak as 02/03 - 04/05 season. That middle year wasn't so great, though.

Yao's peak years ... probably 06/07-08/09.

I'll go with McGrady.

 

I'd say that it's about even between the both of them.

 

Yao has seen the 2nd round, T-Mac has not... Ill take Yao

 

Yao is slow and fumbles the ball at the end of games.At least Tmac can get off a shot.

But I would build my franchise around neither. Wiesbord realized that before a lot of other people.

 

And there is no point of comparing yao to anyone, he will win. Put yao against lebron and i wouldn't be shocked if yao won the poll.

 

Do you want to say TMac dragged Yao's legs and Yao should have pass the first round earlier without TMac.

 

Tracy had his best seasons in Orlando.

 

Not necessarily. T-mac was on the decline when we got him.

 

he was really good in 04-05.

 

easily Tmac

 

First of all 06-07 tmac>04-05 tmac so no he wasn't on the decline when rox first aquired him. Second of all assuming yao and mcgrady stay in their primes for the same amount of time, then any sane person would pick mcgrady in half a heart beat. You'd have to be an absolute asinine to pick prime yao over prime mcgrady. Prime t-mac is the second or third best SG of all time. Prime Yao would be lucky to crack top 15 centers. If you said yao and really meant it then please stop watching basketball cause the sport is clearly not for you.

 

Give me 04-05 tmac anyday. Yao is too easily to shutdown.

 

Obviously, this poll is going to be Yao sided.

But there is no way you can pass on a McGrady especially in his first year in Houston.