Voting is based on front court, back court, overall offence, inside offence, outside shooting, overall defence, post defence, perimeter defence, bench, chemistry...and then individual match-ups (starting line up only) If you score a point for each, that is 15 points total, there should be a winner decided. bigmaloe PG - Oscar Robertson SG - Dwyane Wade SF - LeBron James PF - Bob Pettit C - Patrick Ewing Bench: Grant Hill Chris Bosh Artis Gilmore vs sc1211 PG: Steve Nash SG: Joe Dumars SF: Alex English PF: Kevin Garnett C: Kareem Abdul-Jabaar Bench: Glen Rice Bill Walton Sidney Moncrief
Front Court: SC11 Back Court: bigmaloe Overall Offense: SC11.. Inside Offense: SC11 Outside Shooting: SC11 Overall Defense: BigMaloe - Reeeallyy tough!! Post Defense: SC11 Perimeter Defense: BigMaloe Bench: SC11 Chemistry: BigMaloe Individual Matchups PG - Oscar Robertson SG - Dwyane Wade SF - LeBron James PF - Bob Pettit C - Patrick Ewing vs sc1211 PG: Steve Nash SG: Joe Dumars SF: Alex English PF: Kevin Garnett C: Kareem Abdul-Jabaar 8-7.... Winner: Sc1211
Front Court: SC11 Back Court: bigmaloe Overall Offense: SC11.. Inside Offense: SC11 Outside Shooting: SC11 Overall Defense: TIE Post Defense: SC11 Perimeter Defense: BigMaloe Bench: SC11 Chemistry: TIE Individual Matchups PG - Oscar Robertson SG - Dwyane Wade SF - LeBron James PF - Bob Pettit C - Patrick Ewing vs sc1211 PG: Steve Nash SG: Joe Dumars SF: Alex English PF: Kevin Garnett C: Kareem Abdul-Jabaar 8-5... Winner is Sc1211
Front Court: SC11 Back Court: bigmaloe Overall Offense: SC11 Inside Offense: SC11 Outside Shooting: SC11 Overall Defense: SC11 Post Defense: SC11 Perimeter Defense: BigMaloe Bench: SC11 Chemistry: bigmaloe Individual Matchups PG - Oscar Robertson SG - Dwyane Wade SF - LeBron James PF - Bob Pettit C - Patrick Ewing vs sc1211 PG: Steve Nash SG: Joe Dumars SF: Alex English PF: Kevin Garnett C: Kareem Abdul-Jabaar SC:9 Bigmaloe:6
Front court: SC1211 Back court: BigMaloe Overall offence: SC1211 Inside offence: SC1211 Outside shooting: SC1211 Overall defence: SC1211 Post defence: SC1211 Perimeter defence: BigMaloe Bench: SC1211 Chemistry: Tie Individual Matchups PG - Oscar Robertson SG - Dwyane Wade SF - LeBron James PF - Bob Pettit C - Patrick Ewing vs. sc1211 PG: Steve Nash SG: Joe Dumars SF: Alex English PF: Kevin Garnett C: Kareem Abdul-Jabaar SC1211: 9 BigMaloe:5
[Front Court] SC1211. [Back Court] BigMaloe. [Overall Offense] BigMaloe. [Inside Offense] SC1211. [Outside Shooting] SC1211. [Overall Defense] SC1211. [Post Defense] SC1211. [Perimeter Defense] TIE. [Bench] SC1211. [Chemistry] SC1211. [Point Guard] BigMaloe. [Shooting Guard] BigMaloe. [Small Forward] BigMaloe. [Power Forward] SC1211. SC1211. [WINNER] SC1211.
i dont know how my overall offense isn't better...i lose front court sure but bot as much as he loses in the back... i dominate the backcourt and its nowhere near close.... how does he stop bigO from scoring? with nash he cant... how does he stop lebron? english and rice aint doin it... moncrief can slow down but not stop him... My outside shot isnt SupeR high % but all players score easily and with effeciency, even if its not 3's... nor how my defense isn't better... i got mr triple double himself along with another triple double machine in lebron... i got the most underrated player on this bbs in bob pettit... its whatever thought not tripping... as a side note... i hate this new judging style... i honestly doubt anyone is actually going in depth to think about the matchups but rather just going with it off of first thought...
no one is actually THINKING... they are just like ugh i like this i like that, but they arent taking the time to write out thier opinions... numerous times i had liked one team but after writing and explaing i realized the other team was better and it changed my mind... hate to sound bitter because im not, its just i dont see how anyone is gonna stop a lebron bigO combo... but like jamers said... its more individual matchups now, which is funny because i win 3 out of 5 according to everyone yet still lose.... its so much nicer when you get a well thought responsive answer instead of picks... it waters it down and makes it just for show imo... no elaboration and its just who has the more popular team...
I would love next time if we could do write UPS for our teams about how we utilize our players. If I had known so much would be about the individual I would have drafted more for name than fit. As an aside about stopping your backcourt Maloe, Moncrief and Dumars are two of the best perimeter defenders in NBA history.
front court: sc1211 -- Garnett and Kareem is a wicked duo, and I actually think they fit very well together. I like LeBron over English, but the KG/KA-J combo gives them the edge. back court: bigmaloe -- Oscar and Wade get the edge, primarily due to athleticism. inside offence: sc1211 -- Having the best scorer in NBA history goes a long way, and KG/English are no slouches in the paint. outside shooting: sc1211 -- Having Rice and Nash gives sc the edge. overall offence: bigmaloe -- Interesting, but I will give the overall offensive edge to maloe, even after awarding sc with the better inside offence and outside shooting. The main reason is that I really like maloe's ability to pentrate and move the ball around. overall defence: bigmaloe -- I don't think either of these teams are great defensively. maloe gets the slight edge because sc's team has the worst overall defender of the lot (Nash). post defence: sc1211 -- Primarily due to KG perimeter defence: bigmaloe -- Dumars is great, but Wade/Oscar is better than Dumars/Nash, I think. bench: sc1211 -- sc gets the edge because his bench is more well-balanced. maloe has no backup guard to bring into the lineup. chemistry: sc1211 -- The LeBron/Wade/Bosh connection is nice, but I actually think having both LeBron and Oscar on the same team might possibly be a bit of a disadvantage because their skill sets are very similar. Both need to be the alpha dog in order to be most effective. Overall, I think sc1211's players complement each other better. bigmaloe PG - Oscar Robertson SG - Dwyane Wade SF - LeBron James PF - Bob Pettit C - Patrick Ewing vs sc1211 PG: Steve Nash SG: Joe Dumars SF: Alex English PF: Kevin Garnett C: Kareem Abdul-Jabaar sc1211 wins 8-7. Another close match up!
i agree... i would like to hear write ups... and yes moncrief and dumars are great defenders but they cant keep up with the speed and athleticism... i built my team on an offense style, penetration, good ballmovement, PnR... as a matter of fact im gonna do a write up for this matchup.....
bigmaloe PG - Oscar Robertson/LeBron James SG - Dwyane Wade/Grant Hill SF - LeBron James/Grant Hill PF - Bob Pettit/Chris Bosh C - Patrick Ewing/Artis Gilmore vs sc1211 PG: Steve Nash SG: Joe Dumars SF: Alex English PF: Kevin Garnett C: Kareem Abdul-Jabaar Bench: Glen Rice Bill Walton Sidney Moncrief Frontcourt- Who has the better FC SC1211 - I consider the 3 both front and backcourt... SC has the most unstoppable hook shot and shot ever in kareem, along with a perfect compliment in KG... the defense duo in the post with these two is fantastic... Pettit is good and will out-hustle kg, not too mention he was a beast on the boards, but kg is better... Ewing was nice with a good offense and defense and a great blocker, but i dont see him blockin many of kareems hooks... Lebron dominates english, no explanation needed... but overall Sc's front is better... Backcourt- Who has the better BC BigMaloe - This isn't close... nash is a great facilitator especially on the fast break, but whos dangerous enough to run full-court with him? plus his defense is horrid...on the other side bigO averaged a triple double, plus he has the heighth advantage for sure... Dumars is a great defender and i think he can slow wade down a little, but this flash, dumars cant contain his speed all game... again lebron >>>>>> english... Bench- WHo has the better bench Tie - bill walton and moncrief off the bench is very nice offense comin from the second unit... glen rice brings the only offense tho, and while he was a great 3 pointer im worried about the bench offense... grant hill was a beast who i wish injuries didnt occur to, because IMO he would be one of the greatest ever(top 25) his defense was superb and offense and athleticism were very good also... artis gilmore brings post defense similiar to walton except at a notch below... bosh gets whippped for being 'soft' but he is one of the best stretch 4's ever and can play both sides... but the talent and skills offset and are so close its hard to decide, thus its a tie... Offense- Which team has the better overall team offense. Which teams offense would run smoother and be more effective. BigMaloe - the unselfishness and dominance of the overall team is superb... i imagine bigO, wade, lebron runnin transition, siiick... when bigO sits lebron takes over and is essentially the same exact thing... ewing could score along with pettit, nice, but SC's defense and post presence diminishes Maloe's FC...the biggest problem with the team is 3pt shooting... while bosh can shoot the 3, as well as wade and lebron, not as super high percentage... TBH im confused on what offense SC would run... nash is gonna push tempo, and kareem could likely keep up, but i dont fear kg, english and dumars on the fast break(especially with wade and lebron closing!) obviously he's better suited on the halfcourt and while nash is good still at the half court hes, better with transition... still feeding the ball thru the post of kareem and kg and kickin it out to rice and nash is nice... but overall i like the build of Maloe's... Defense- Which team plays better defense? This includes team defense as well as individual defense BigMaloe - every player on maloe's team plays both offense and defense except gilmore, but gilmore does play D...... lebron is great and has the wings locked... he can gaurd 1 thru 5... if nash/dumars/english/kg/rice start getting hot lebron can cool him off... kareem and kg is great post defense, along with moncrief and dumars on the wing... i see SC winning the post defense and offense, its far more superior, but BigMaloe dominates both sides of the BC... Nash is a huge weak spot... he plays no defense and BigMaloes strenth is BigO with lebron relieving him, how do you stop that? moncrief and dumars can try but not seeing it... Chemistry- which team would have better chemistry and work together better. For example, a team full of scorers who like to keep the ball in their hands wouldn't work very well. BigMaloe - I dont see any chemistry pproblems for either team, and envision kareem and KG meshing perfectly, but i'll lean towards the trio of bosh/wade/lebron who won a ring together(so far)... BigMaloe in 7... i honestly see it about tempo, if its a slow game with half court sets and feeding the post SC could have the advantage... problem is bigO/lebron/wade are gonna push and push... and then nash will get the urge to also push, playing into the strenth of maloe... thats my honest opinion and forethought... SC1211 no offense about what i've been saying... you put a terrific team together, and you win rightfully so because thats how the judges felt... i just wish there was critique and in-depth analysis.. by picking this name that name left me wondering (How do i not win this section? how'd i lose this part? etc..) if i could have had insight on why judges felt they did that would be better and different... but honestly the only weakness i see is not having a dominate 3pt shooter... GG well played...
its not... but im gonna do it for every matchup... you can choose names if you want and provide no explanation if you want... seems like laziness to me...
FC: SC BC: Bigmaloe Ovrl Offense: SC Inside Offense: SC Outside Shooting: SC Overall Defense: Bigmaloe Post Defense: SC Perimeter Defense: Bigmaloe Bench: Bigmaloe Chemistry: SC 4-6 SC Matchups: bigmaloe PG - Oscar Robertson SG - Dwyane Wade SF - LeBron James PF - Bob Pettit C - Patrick Ewing vs sc1211 PG: Steve Nash SG: Joe Dumars SF: Alex English PF: Kevin Garnett C: Kareem Abdul-Jabaar 3-2 Bigmaloe Overall 7-8 Winner: SC