Rookie of The Year for 2003

If anyone says T.J. Ford, they are delusional...


























...and full of ****.

 

If you look at the Bucks lineup you have to put T.J. in the running.

 

yea T.J. should be up there BUT this is a 2 mans game, James and Anthony. As of right now i have to go with Anthony i mean look at Denvers record this team wasnt suppose to make the playoffs remember? This guy has helped them turn it around. True L. James has better #s but Wins always count more than hype or numbers as we learned last year with Yao & Amari.

 

This year alone

Carmelo > LeBron

LeBron > T.J.

LeBron > Bosh

Bosh > T.J.

 

Bosh plays on a much better team that Ford. Analysts thought Milwakee would be one of the worst teams in the East. He has had more impact on his team.

 

Lebron is awesome, and he makes better commercials.

Edge: Lebron.

Carmelo's "I'm not Michael Jordan, I'm his student" sucks.

 

Since when is ROY about the commercials. If it was, then Yao would have won in a walk

 

Carmelo will take the Nugz to the playoffs and have similar numbers as James, but somehow I still think Lebron will win the ROY award. Or maybe a Co ROY thing might take place like Kidd and Hill.

 

any reason why you think carmelo is better than lebron? lebron's stats are by far better.

if its the team's record then i would have to argue that adding andre miller, lenard, and a healthy camby is helping more than just carmelo.

 

But also playing in the West is against Carmelo's favor and playing with those player he is still putting up impressive numbers. while james being the #1 option has showed he can play, but can he win is another story.

 

Or like freakin Francis and Brand.........THAT WAS GAY. FRANCIS should'a been sole ROY.

 

I would trade the rocket's ROY for either one of them.

 

yep

and IMO it should have been co ROY last year.

 

Dwyane (yes that is how you spell it) Wade is creating quite a buzz in Miami as of late. Back to back 30 points games last week I believe. Helping me kick everyone's ass in my fantasy league. I really was pulling for Carmelo, but It appears Lebron is the reincarnation of Magic Johnson.

 

What!!!

 

it's hard to pick. LbJ is going bananas but Melo's team is winning...so just by that unwritten law (that was used last year)...Melo gets the nod.

 

I think lebron is probably going to win it... by a hair
but I like carmelo high arc shot

If i can vote.. I'll vote for carmelo