reporter arrested for asking giuliani aide a question after debate

and the guy doesnt try to walk away - he is talking to him. he asks him to show him the documentation and when the reporter offers is when the cops come. he wasnt impeding him in any way - the guy wasnt trying to get away from him.

actually, it is very different - the reporter never engaged in slander or personal insults like the guy that buzz punched. it is also different b/c the guy being questioned did not seek to break contact - he was talking to him.

i never said it was innocent or polite - he was asking a hard question - giuliani was caught in a lie and his aide was being questioned about it. but i guess in the new america that is something that gets people arrested.

 

even if he was, that is not an arrestable offense.

 

for the second time, i never said he was asking polite questions. in fact, i said he was asking hard questions. the aide's boss was caught in a lie and the reporter was asking him to explain it. he was being aggressive, but that isnt the first time a reporter has been so, is it?

still waiting for you to explain to me how asking a question constitutes "stalk and harass" or is deserving of arrest?

 

what does any of this have to do with being a ron paul supporter? what are you seeing on the video? i see a guy with a legitimate press pass, who had every right to be there, get arrested for asking a question.

i am a supporter of the first amendment. its a shame that more of us are not.

 

i accept your apology.

 

i never heard him yell "you are a liar". he said "giuliani lied to me". even if he had called the guy a liar, why should he get arrested for it? the guy asked him for documentation and when the reporter offered to show it to him he was dragged off.

what paranoid delusion would that be? giuliani was caught in a lie and the reporter was asking his aide to explain it. it was a hard question and he was aggressive, but he had every right to be there and he did nothing illegal.

 

he wasnt outside of camera view during the exchange and if he had done something to warrant getting arrested before the exchange he should have been already removed from the event.

the police station confirmed that he was being charged with felony criminal trespass (even though he had a press pass and was allowed to be there).

 

here is more on the lie that tranny giuliani was caught in and the reporter wanted the aide to explain.

http://rawstory.com/news/2007/Video_tribute_to_Giuliani_911_lies_0530.html

On Tuesday, members of a 911 truth activist group confronted former Mayor Rudy Giuliani at a New York fundraiser about the fall of the World Trade Center.

"How come people in the buildings weren't notified?" asked one member of the group. "And how can you sleep at night?"

Giuliani's politely-phrased response, caught by WNBC newscameras filming the event, was "I didn't know that the towers were going to collapse."

That response contradicts remarks the former New York City mayor made about being warned about the collapse during a phone interview with onetime ABC anchor Peter Jennings on September 11, 2001, as shown in a transcript WNBC obtained from the Giuliani 2008 campaign.

Giuliani told Jennings, "I--I went down to the scene and we set up headquarters at 75 Barkley Street, which was right there with the police commissioner, the fire commissioner, the head of emergency management, and we were operating out of there when we were told that the World Trade Center was going to collapse. And it did collapse before we could actually get out of the building, so we were trapped in the building for 10, 15 minutes, and finally found an exit and got out, walked north, and took a lot of people with us."