Well, he was just in the hospital for his pnemonia less than one week ago... there's no way he can be fully back strength-wise. Also, Lidge's "stuff" is just that much more intimidating in a save situation.... although he definitely proved me wrong in last year's game 6 of the playoffs, where he held the Cards at bay for 3 extra innings.
It has to be Lidge's loss. It's a shame he crumbled tonight, but with his recent flu/hospital stay, it was almost a sure thing he wasn't full strength.
Also, before Lidge's illness... we hadn't given him a decent save opportunity in ages. He's gotta be completely out of sync.... I don't think he's ever pitched this sporadically at any point in his big league career. Jimy always called on him big-time, and then Garner.
lidge is a stud, he's the last person on this team that i'd ever worry about, even behind roger. no question he still felt the effects of the week before as his fastball was like 3mph slower. i'll bet we don't see another outing like this from him for YEARS. tough ass loss though.