Pakistan to execute Christian mother who verbally insulted Muhammed

Why do you dance around it? You defend sanctions for blasphemy, even compare it to Hitler and Saddam (facepalm ), but you are not man enough to tell us what you would regard as an appropriate punishment for this "criminal"?

 

I never compared it to Hitler or Saddam, Again you repeatedly show signs of a lower intelligence. Obviously reading comprehension has failed you throughout life.

How do you feel that Germany is against just "saying words". Article 166 of German Criminal Law

Hypocrite.

 

I see nothing good in this. A cleric making out like her death sentence is the happiest day of his life? Umm...you call yourself religious? You should be ashamed. Same with these villlage people. We are religious but we rejoice over a death sentence for a few misdirected words of a non-believer at that.

It's a joke and does nothing to help the image of Islam.

 

Answer the question: What punishment do you deem appropriate for her?

 

Agreed

 

Is blasphemy punishable by death in Germany?

 

Do you disagree with the German constitution?

 

I never said it was. We are having a discussion about Blasphemy being more than "just words". Clearly many nations in this day and age disagree with the premise that Blasphemy is simply just words.

 

Can you post a link to Article 166.

The German Constitution only has 146 Articles.

 

you said execution is justified in regards to blasphemy, so why is this case any different?

 

1. Yes

2. Educated in what sense?

3. I never said I agree with the punishment she is receiving.

 

They might be words that you do not agree with and find incredibly insulting, but they are still words.

 

I guess its not the constitution, rather something called the Strafgesetzbuches (German Criminal Law)

http://www.gesetze-im-internet.de/englisch_stgb/index.html

 

Then what punishment do you deem appropriate?

 

I am curious adeelsiddiqui... if you were the judge or based off your knowledge of Islam what would you deem a appropriate punishment for this women who in my view committed no crime. It was just an argument between two people and words were said.

 

Who said that?

I said execution is justified in regards to someone saying "just words". In some cases, words can and do justify execution.

Obviously we all agree with Obama's execution orders against American Cleric Anwar Awlaki. All he did was just "say words"...

 

Section 166

"Defamation of religions,
religious and ideological associations

(1) Whosoever publicly or through dissemination of written materials (section 11 (3)) defames the religion or ideology of others in a manner that is capable of disturbing the public peace, shall be liable to imprisonment of not more than three years or a fine.

(2) Whosoever publicly or through dissemination of written materials (section 11 (3)) defames a church or other religious or ideological association within Germany, or their institutions or customs in a manner that is capable of disturbing the public peace, shall incur the same penalty."

 

There is no crime here. She said stuff against what was basically a village mob. Her fight/flight situation kicked in and she said stuff that she obviously never meant or even understood. Even if she said committed treason in that state of fear, I dont think she really did any crime.

 

Still mere "words"... How can a country have laws against someone just stirring up peoples emotions? How dare they...