Official "Should I" Thread

When 2 sucky teams play on a neutral field, anything can happen. I had Minny's D vs Cleveland. Fantasy wise, it wasn't horrible bc of the ints and fumbles, but Cleveland tore them up hard. If Pittsburgh fixes their TO issues, this could be a bad fantasy day for Minny.

 

Maurice Jones Drew instead of Giovanni Bernard?

Also, if I can convince some one else to take MJD for Pierre Garcon and Whitten, would that be a better trade?

 

I have:

Eli (dropping him for Rivers)
D. Martin
Spiller
R. Bush

Should I trade Spiller for McFadden + Vick?

 

I like Bernard's upside. He's an explosive young back, and his workload is only going to increase as the season progresses. He has 3 TDs in the last 2 weeks and may wind up nabbing the starting job come late October/November.

The Garcon-Witten deal is probably slightly better, but don't sleep on Torrey Smith. He has quietly had a very nice start to the season as the clear-cut #1 target in Baltimore.

 

Man that is a hard one. Vick is the #2 qb so far this year. I have been starting him over room since week 2.

 

He's a big (albeit risky) upgrade over Eli, but am I selling Spiller too low/buying McFadden too high?

 

Would you guys consider replacing Knoshown Moreno for Le'Veon Bell in your starting lineup this week?

 

na, i would keep moreno in the starting lineup

le'veon bell is still injured..and if he does play, i don't think his impact is that significant

but moreno, playing a moderate eagles' defense..yeah i would start him

but what do others think?


also do i start kenbrell thompkins or eddie royal over andre johnson this week? or should I keep AJ in the starting lineup?

 

I would still stick with Andre unless he can't go.

Brian Hartline at NO or Denarius Moore vs. Washington?

 

Hartline, if Pryor cannot go.

 

I'm trying to dump MJD. If I can get Jordan Cameron or Julius Thomas for him would you do it.

I'm starting Kyle Rudolph at TE right now and the other guy has both Thomas and Cameron and could use a RB (even a washed up one like MJD) he has Chris Johnson, Woodhead, Bernard and Lamar Miller.

Thinking of offering MJD and Daniel Thomas (so he could handcuff Miller) for Cameron or Thomas whichever he wants to dump. Am I giving up to much?

 

Honestly, I don't see anyone giving up Jordan Cameron at this point unless it's for a RB1 or Jimmy Graham.

 

He has Julius Thomas starting this week and Cameron on the bench. We can't start two TEs in our league. I think he could get a better offer but I doubt anyone would want to trade a RB since quality ones are scarce this year.

 

Should I start Coby Fleener (on the road against Jacksonville) or DeAndre Hopkins in my Flex? I really hate the idea of Hopkins against the Seattle defense and love the idea of anybody versus Jacksonville.

My starting receivers this week are AJ Green and Cecil Shorts (since Jordy Nelson has a bye) and my TE is Jason Witten.

 

Tough. I'd go Hopkins. I see Indy running all day, and us the opposite.

 

Definitely get Cameron for MJD.

 

I traded Deandre Hopkins for Hakeem Nicks. How badly did I rip my friend off?

 

Sort of. Nicks is a HUGE injury risk. DeAndre could be the #1 if Andre stays down. DeAndre is more fun to root for.

 

I countered with Cameron+Spiller for Lynch+McFadden+Vick.

Thoughts?

 

LOL, my trade just got turned down. I tried Lynch + Cameron for CJ2k + Graham. Was trying to sell high on Cameron but the guy is apparently not high on Lynch and has a boner for Graham...