Official "Should I" Thread

Agree, the trade was in his favor before adding Daniels. You must have come off as really desperate for Foster.

 

I'm thinking of trading CJ Spiller for Adrian Peterson straight up my current running backs are

RB: Arian foster, Alfred Morris and Chris Johnson

Should i do it?

Currently Spiller has more touchdowns more receiving yards and more fantasy value in terms of where he's rank compared to Adrian Peterson. Spiller is not as consistent as Adrian Peterson especially now that he's sharing the ball with Fred Jackson. Would you do it?

 

I don't think trading the leagues leading rusher and receiver was worth it period.

 

I would

I traded Spiller myself for Peyton Manning. I love Spiller, but you can't count on him to get more than 15 touches.

 

I'm not saying Spiller is Jamaal Charles, but Jamaal Charles finished a top RB in 2010 getting the lesser workload in a timesplit with Jones, and averaging 14-15 carries a game. Gailey won't run like Haley did, so it likely won't happen, and moving Spiller for AP is close to a no brainer.

 

Goddamnit. I guess I did seem desperate. My reasoning was that I wanted someone more consistent week to week than Charles, and that the AJ Green scoring rate can't last much longer let alone the rest of the season.

Funny thing is I felt he was more desperate but it seems I got played

 

Pretty much my thought on him as well.

 

AJ Green is a beast. Charles is a beast. Problem is you didn't capitalize on increased value. If they drop off, the trade becomes equal. If it was Green, and one of your lesser backs, or Charles and one of your lesser receivers, it would have been a good deal for you.

 

Absolutely. AP is an absolute stud and the touchdowns will come. Git 'r done.

 

Should I... Trade Andre Johnson and Darren Sproles to get LeSean McCoy?

 

yes. yes you should

 

I have Darren Sproles, and I'm looking to trade him for a WR. What caliber WR do you guys think Sproles is worth? Demaryius Thomas? Jordy Nelson?

Standard scoring league.

 

I have 11 team bball roto draft today, 10 categories I have pick was planning to take whoever was left of Paul or Love but can't see how I can still take Love now, leaning towards Aldridge or maybe Westbrook, what do y'all think?

 

You don't think Sproles is worth a Jordy Nelson? Why not?

The way I see it, Nelson's value will decrease whenever Jennings returns, Sproles is a more consistent player, and Sproles has already has his bye week. Also, running backs are inherently more valuable than wide receivers.

So what caliber WR do you think Sproles is worth?

 

I traded Brandon Lloyd, who has been rotting on my bench, straight up for Kyle Rudolph. My current starting TE is Daniel's. Good move by me? I already have Andre, Victor, and Jordy starting

 

Who are your running backs? What do you plan to do when Andre and Jordy have their bye weeks?

 

My runningbacks are McGahee and MJD, and I just picked up Jonathon Dwyer for this week. Behind Andre and Jordy I have Crabtree and Meachem, which can be decent fillers IMO.

 

I am in need of a TE, my current lineup is

QB: P. Manning, A. Luck
RB: A. Foster, A. Morris, C.J. Spiller, Chris Johnson
WR: Roddy White, Percy Harvin, Andre Johnson, Miles Austin, D. Bowe
TE: Dennis Pitta, Greg Olsen

I am thinking of giving up two WR for a REALLY good TE, maybe Jimmy Graham, Gronkowski or Tony Gonzalez OR my other option a WR for a decent TE Kyle Rudolph.

What do you guys think?

 

I'd go after a top TE. The gap between the top TEs and the next teir is huge, and it your teams flaw.