Official "Should I" Thread

I like them in that order.

 

started cutler/marshall in one league

started rodgers in another league

started finley/cobb in a 3rd league.

dammit.

 

Meh. Rodgers and Marshall will be fine this year. You had to know Cobb/Finley would be inconsistent going in.

 

Surprised by the lack of targets.

 

Green Bay really comitted to getting Benson going last night.

 

Good news: Opponent sat Benson last night. - 11pts
Bad news: I sat GB's defense. - 19pts

Come on Cincy!

 

Luckily I didn't budge on Green Bay's D. Started them and reaped the rewards for Cutler's suckage.

 

in a 3 wr league

Brees

roddy white
mike wallace
eric decker

murray
hillis

fred davis

lance moore

Bench
ronnie brown
hillman
lefall
collie
tate
schaub

I need help at the rb spot

here are my options

CJ spiller or Trent Richardson for Mike Wallace
Michael Bush for Eric Decker
Cedric Benson for Lance Moore

What should I do??

Thanks in advance

 

I'd do Moore for Benson. Mike Wallace is a lot to give up for Spiller (with Fred Jackson coming back eventually) and for Richardson who is still a big risk as a rookie on a terrible team.

 

What RBs are in FA?

If not much. I would move LaFell to flex and do trade for Benson.

 

thanks..i think im leaning towards moore for benson as well

the team im trying to trade with also has doug martin ridley benson david wilson jaq rodgers (atl)

You think i can mix match and get a better deal?

opinions change if Forte is out longer?

 

See if he will do Moore/Brown

for

Benson/Wilson

or some other wr on his bench with upside.

 

I dropped them to go with Oak vs Mia... might come back to bite me in the ass.

 

In another league, I have waiver 1

Mark Ingram, David Wilson, and Ryan Williams are all available

I would be dropping Nate Washington

Any preference?

Im debating between wilson and Ingram and leaning Wilson

 

I have zero faith in any New Orleans RB having consistent standard league value.

I like Wilson's potential but Bradshaw will still get his. I think Williams right now has the best chance to seize a starting job, but he's got to outperform Beanie Wells this week.

 

R. Williams, Dwyer, Helu, Hunter, Wilson, Starks, J. Rodgers, Leshoure, Turbin... at least 2 of those guys are gonna start at some point.

 

LeShoure and Hunter

 

Should I drop Celek for Marcedes Lewis for my TE2?

 

I wouldnt

 

Ok,I have been working on a trade that would patch up some of my weaknesses.

P Manning
D McFadden
M Lynch
R White
D Bowe
B Lloyd
B Pettigrew
L Zuerlien
Tampa Bay D

I want to upgrade my D, and I found someone willing to part with OAK D. Is that a D that I can run with all season?

Bench
B Tate
M Leshoure
S Rice
M Manningham
D Jones
J Tamme

In 20 team league I will need another QB sometime this season and this guy has Cassel as his backup. He is interested in S Rice and he has A Foster and I have Tate for the handcuff.

Do you think a trade is somewhat possible that looks like this.
I give
S Rice
B Tate

For
Oakland D
M Cassel

I would like to get more out of the deal since I am am giving my two best backups. What if I add M Manningham as filler and ask for either B Lafell or T Gerhart as part of the deal, what do you think?