(Official) American Idol Season 5 Thread

Why are you cracking on Cowell? He wanted Chris to win.

 

I am in shock, I think Chris was the only one I would buy a ticket to go see in concert.

Taylor at a club, but not on a big stage......

America....you got it wrong !!


DD

 

Hicks Taylor over Cris, LOL America.

 

Sweet.

Missed the show, but I still don't get all the Chris worshipping. He's not that good.

Did Paula cry?

 

America... Your next American Idol.



I like Hicks, but it cracks me up how many people hate him.

 

there are some good songs from his band absent element. i think he'd definitley make a good album.

 

I think he used Simon's name because he's executive producer (or something like that) of the show.....

 

Simon Fuller is the executive producer. Simon Cowell is not a producer of AI.

 

Ahhh...my bad. I thought that Simon had something to do with the show in that regard. I also remembered seeing a bunch of "Simon"s on the credit listings, and I guess I just figured one of them had to be Cowell.

 

Bah. I think everyone was suprised. I never liked Chris anyway.

Here's hoping to a Taylor-Katharine final, because Taylor would eat Elliot's soul.

 

Well then Elliott wins based on your prediction history.

 

You might be thinking of AI = American Inventor which Cowell does Produce on ABC I think??

 

didnt watch the show but by reading this thread I am truely shocked...I had no clue or hint that Chris would be the one to go home. My thought after last nights songs, is that Cahtherine and Elliot were the 2 who could go home......Catherine had just a bad night and well Elliot is Elliot.

There is no doubt in my mind right now that Chris will make it...he could of quit the show a long time ago and still make hits. Chris, in my opinion, has always been the most ready for making records....again Im surprised.

 

i dont watch the show after that first 2 weeks or so...tell me..is the girl with the jugs still on?

 

Then that a** should have supported him more.


I'm with DaDakota. Chris is the only one that I'd spend money on. The others...even if they have good pipes...are boring. I could see how Elliot could entertain many, but his style doesn't do it for me. As for the other two...I keep envisioning the lounge... Star Wars....nothin but... Star Wars...

 

Man, I really can't believe all the uproar over Chris. He's not that good, people. Some of the people I work with are acting like he's frickin' John Lennon or something.

 

I guess those people have a different opinion about how good Chris is than you, eh?

DD

 

I predicted that Elliot and Paris would be in the bottom two the previous week, and that Paris would be gone.

I'm 50%.

 

I don't get the love for Elliot. He bores the hell out of me.

Taylor will win.