Tee Martin, Marc Bulger, Chris Redman, Spergon Wynn, Chad Pennington, and Giovanni Carmazzi. #nevrfoget
Brady consistently does more with less, IMO. Brady also owns the head to head with Manning 11-4, I believe. Lastly, rings as well as overall playoff success... Brady for me without question.
Brady every day of the week, and twice on Sunday. They're both hall of famers, but it's still not even close in my opinion.
Manning. Brady's been tied to one coach the whole time. I don't know if Brady could have the same success elsewhere.
I'm the opposite. I'm becoming more and more convinced over time that BRADY is in fact the biggest reason for Belichick's success rather than the other way around.
Both guys make their teammates better and have a lot in common. But I'd go with Manning who can basically run his own offense by himself. Brady is a competitor, he studies hard, he's a leader. But he's not the creative offensive director that Manning can be. Brady has more talent, bigger arm right now. Manning just makes it happen. I'm sick and tired of hearing about Tom Brady this year though. What the Patriots are doing right now has little to do with Tom Brady. This year has been all about Bill Belichick. This is his masterpiece. Nobody can say, "well, Belichick had Brady" - not anymore. Right now, Brady has Belichick. If anything you can question Brady's talent over Belichick's at this point. Cassel did well for them and Brady doesn't lead all of those ring-winning drives without the help of one of the most clutch kickers of all time. Who won all those big games? Brady? Or Vinatieri?
Brady has had BB as his coach since he came into this league. Manning had various coaches , Dungy is a good coach. So many debatable points .
