I understand that people have different tastes. My reason is due to other threads like ones for Kate Upton. Soooo many people (although I'm sure they're just more outspoken about it) talk about how she's not hot. No idea how anyone can say 'no' to Upton and yes to Maggie. However, let me backtrack... I'd bang Maggie for sure, solely because she's famous. I'd probably do Oprah too by that reasoning. But, if Maggie were not famous and I saw her in a bar, I'd take her only above some fatties.
Regarding Michelle Williams- Your point being? (pretty sure most guys on here would run off with Michelle Williams in a millisecond. Also pretty sure if Michelle Williams and Maggie Gylls were in a bar, Williams would draw most if not all the men). Actually maybe it is the best benchmark. A guy that out of his mind(re. the stopping his own heart thing) still would rather smash her brother than her in a flick.