Eddie Vanderdoes or Vanderdoesn't

heypartner · Jun 1, 2013

NCAA Football drame...lols

If you're following the story, a "5-star" DL recruit signed a letter of intent and is trying to get out of it to sign with another college.

Is this a bad precedent for NCAA recruiting if it is allowed to happen without missing a year of eligibility? I'm also curious how common this is. Does it happen in basketball?

I'm biased a little because it involved Notre Dame, but I don't really care too much because NCAA football is not high on my list of sports. Honestly curious what you NCAA football fans think.

Here's a good explanation at UCLA fan site about the rules and what we know to date.

Bruinsnation said:

http://www.bruinsnation.com/ucla_br...eddie-vanderdoes-ucla-notre-dame-decommit-loi

Some relevant points:

The process: There is an established process for a player that has submitted a signed LOI to request release from that letter.

The student and his or her parent/guardian submits an online form which is then sent to the athletic director and NCAA compliance officer at the relevant school (Notre Dame, in EV's case).

The school can either grant a complete release from the letter, allowing the player to be recruited by and enroll at any NCAA-member school; not grant a release but remove the ban on other schools recruiting the player; or refusal to release the player from the NLI and continue to bar other NCAA-member schools from recruiting the player. The school must take one of those actions within 30 days of receiving the request (or the release is automatically granted). Notre Dame has done the latter.

If the request for release is denied, the player can file an appeal with the organization which governs the NLI process. The appeal, with supporting information must be filed within 30 days of the denial of release. The school then can submit its evidence supporting the refusal to release the player. The decision of that NLI committee can be appealed (PDF) by either party to a final NLI Appeals Committee, within 30 days of the prior decision.

The timelines are all rather confusing, but the rule of thumb given by the NLI committee is that the appeals process usually takes 6-8 weeks. That is after the player's decision to seek a release from his/her NLI, and the school's initial denial of the request. We can't say for certain where in the process Eddie currently is, but that he is well into the appeals process. That means that whether or not Notre Dame elects to change their stance and free Eddie, there should be a resolution in the next couple of weeks. That also means that whatever the source of the problem between Eddie and ND is, it is not something that just arose - Eddie would have started this process several weeks ago.

On academics. There is a simple provision in the NLI rules: If a committed player does not meet NCAA academic requirements, or is otherwise denied admission to the schools that he/she is committed to, the NLI is declared "null and void". The player is then able to sign a grant-in-aid agreement with any other NCAA school. If, as some Notre Dame board posters (and 'reporters') have speculated, Eddie's problem stems from a problem with one of his HS classes, there can be one of two results: 1) ND admits him anyways; or 2) ND is unable to admit him with the rest of the 2013 class. At the moment that ND refuses to admit him, his NLI becomes void, allowing him to seek enrollment at UCLA (or any other school), making his seeking a release pointless.

If Eddie fails to secure release from his Notre Dame LOI, he can choose to break his commitment by enrolling at UCLA or another NCAA school. He would lose a year of athletic eligibility which he cannot counter by using a redshirt season (the normal 5 years to use 4 years of eligibility becomes 4 years to use 3 years of eligibility). During that year, Eddie can be on a football scholarship and practice with the team.

Click to expand...

J.R. · Jun 4, 2013

Vanderdoes to enroll at UCLA

heypartner · Jun 5, 2013

Thanks for the update, J.R.. I guess if a student is willing to give up a year of eligible then he can do whatever he wants.

Forums

Eddie Vanderdoes or Vanderdoesn't

heypartner Member

J.R. Member

heypartner Member

Share This Page

About ClutchFans

Rockets Content

Support ClutchFans!