I don't see what the problem is honestly. If the guy makes so many threads just don't read them and that's it. I mean it is a fan board where guys are free to do or say what they want. If he gets out of line now that's another situation.
uumm not *totally* true there are restrictions on duplicate threads and threads that could have gone in existing threads. Also, personal attacks, racist statements and other stuff that would not be SFW or are not PG13 are not allowed. on topic.. whether or not you guys like the poster in question, he/she has shown themselves to be better than at least 50% of the other posters in GARM so you guys need to get off his/her case.
What does it mean for his account to be moderated? If that means he can't create new threads for a while or without them being approved, I'm okay with that. I'd prefer him to get bumped down to rookie if he's not allowed to post anything with moderator permission. Granted I don't read much of GARM because of the hyper knee jerk nature of it.
I don't think the problem we have is with his/her posting in general but the number of threads and the topics of some of them. I knew personally from game threads when he/she has actually posted in an existing thread that he/she is a decent poster.