1. Welcome! Please take a few seconds to create your free account to post threads, make some friends, remove a few ads while surfing and much more. ClutchFans has been bringing fans together to talk Houston Sports since 1996. Join us!

Chris Bosh

Discussion in 'NBA Dish' started by jopatmc, Nov 25, 2009.

  1. rockets119

    rockets119 Member

    Joined:
    Oct 13, 2009
    Messages:
    203
    Likes Received:
    1
    its not about effort, bosh gives good effort on D
    its just that his core too weak even with the added weight this off season
    he gets out muscled easily by any big men out there... other than maybe anthony randolph..
    i mean, its like asking yao trying his hardest to guard lebron on the perimeter
    not capable
     
  2. jevjnd

    jevjnd Member

    Joined:
    Apr 18, 2002
    Messages:
    1,496
    Likes Received:
    258
    I've been working on this for a while, but I came up with a trade that would probably work between Golden State, Houston, and Toronto. We'd end up having to sign a bunch of league minimum players and have gaping holes or modify the trade a slight bit, but I think that this trade could go down. Just don't say that I didn't warn you of its ugliness.

    http://www.realgm.com/src_checktrade.php?tradeid=5299250

    Successful Trade Scenario
    Congratulations on a successful trade.

    Due to Toronto, Houston, and Golden State being over the cap, the 25% trade rule is invoked. Toronto, Houston, and Golden State had to be no more than 125% plus $100,000 of the salary given out for the trade to be accepted, which did happen here. This trade satisfies the provisions of the Collective Bargaining Agreement.

    [​IMG]
    By jevjnd2000 at 2009-11-26
    [​IMG]
    By jevjnd2000 at 2009-11-26
    [​IMG]
    By jevjnd2000 at 2009-11-26
     
  3. mikol13

    mikol13 Protector of the Realm
    Supporting Member

    Joined:
    May 31, 2009
    Messages:
    14,344
    Likes Received:
    28,554

    That totally guts the team. Hell that is the team. Far to much to give up. I hope I missed the sarcasm
     
  4. jopatmc

    jopatmc Member

    Joined:
    Sep 4, 2002
    Messages:
    15,370
    Likes Received:
    390

    Don't see a Memphis deal working. Bosh isn't going to sign a long term deal with them. He'd wind up walking. He wants to play for a winner. So Memphis says no. Not only that but Rudy Gay? Don't see Toronto wanting him when they've got Hedo and a rookie to play the wing.
     
  5. jopatmc

    jopatmc Member

    Joined:
    Sep 4, 2002
    Messages:
    15,370
    Likes Received:
    390

    He would fit great into Adelman's system. He can spread the floor by shooting the 3 when Yao is out there. He can run like a gazelle. And when Yao is out and Bosh is in the middle, he can work over the 2nd unit in the paint. He's the perfect fit next to Yao in Adelman's system because he is a floor spacer.
     
  6. jopatmc

    jopatmc Member

    Joined:
    Sep 4, 2002
    Messages:
    15,370
    Likes Received:
    390
    What about a deal for Chris Kaman, Landry, our first rounder, and Cook? Kaman could be pried away from the Clippers if we were willing to take back Baron Davis.

    McGrady, Battier to Clippers.
    Kaman, Landry, Cook to Toronto.
    Davis, Camby, Bosh to Houston.

    Baron is a high price to pay though. However, if I were Morey, it sure would be tempting to get Bosh if Toronto preferred Kaman over Okafor. Another deal where we'd have to sign a swingman or consider trading Lowry for a swingman to balance out our backcourt.

    Still haven't seen any realistic deals that would give Toronto back more talent than we could give them by giving them Landry plus another talent acquired using McGrady's expiring.
     
  7. maw7079

    maw7079 Member

    Joined:
    Jul 24, 2002
    Messages:
    432
    Likes Received:
    129
    PLEASE PLEASE PLEASE Stop trying to trade Landry... trade Scola.... Landry is better and younger and Scola has just as much trade value
     
  8. wekko368

    wekko368 Member

    Joined:
    Jan 3, 2008
    Messages:
    8,915
    Likes Received:
    1,028
    Before you continue posting this drivel, I'm going to give you a few things to considers (I don't feel like detailing each point....that's something for you to figure out).

    1. Why do you think Bosh is that much of an upgrade over Scola/Landry?
    2. Pros/Cons of Bosh playing alongside Yao.
    3. Historical success of an all-star PF and all-star C playing together.
    4. Other Rockets' weaknesses that would be ignored by acquiring Bosh.
     
  9. mustang98

    mustang98 Member

    Joined:
    Feb 17, 2009
    Messages:
    67
    Likes Received:
    53
    How about this trade?


    Houston Rockets Payroll

    $83,375,082
    Cap Room

    -$25,675,082
    Player
    Salary
    PER Being Traded To

    Chris Bosh$15,779,912$15.7M 22.2
    PF6 0 1 Year

    Being Traded To

    P. Stojakovic$13,392,000$13.3M 12.5
    SF5 0 2 Years

    Acquiring 2 Players
    $29,171,912$29.2M
    Houston Rockets Roster

    Being Traded To D. Andersen N/AC9 0 Being Traded To Trevor Ariza$5,854,000$5.8M 15.5SF5 0 4 Years Free AgentRestriction Expires: December 15, 2009After a free agent signs with a team, he cannot be traded for 3 months or until December 15, whichever is later.
    Being Traded To S. Battier$6,939,200$6.9M 10.7SF5 0 2 Years Being Traded To Aaron Brooks$1,118,520$1.1M 12.9PG1 0 2 Years Being Traded To New Orleans Hornets C. Budinger$725,000$725.0K N/ASF5 0 3 Years Being Traded To Brian Cook$3,500,000$3.5M N/APF6 0 1 Year Being Traded To Joey Dorsey$881,000$881.0K N/APF6 0 3 Years Being Traded To Chuck Hayes$2,147,750$2.1M 7.8C9 0 1 Year Being Traded To Carl Landry$3,000,000$3.0M 17.7PF6 0 1 Year Being Traded To Kyle Lowry$2,034,996$2.0M 14.5PG1 0 1 Year Being Traded To New Orleans Hornets T. McGrady$22,843,124$22.8M 16.4SG2 0 1 Year Being Traded To Yao Ming$16,378,325$16.3M 22.7C9 0 2 Years Being Traded To Toronto Raptors Luis Scola$3,284,667$3.2M 17.1PF6 0 1 Year Being Traded To J. Taylor$725,000$725.0K N/AG3 0 3 Years
    Trade Exceptions

    R. Alston$1,400,000$1.4M S. Francis$2,634,480$2.6M J. White$825,497$825.4K
    Hollinger's Analysis: +11 Wins

    With this trade you have increased this team's projected wins by 11.
    New Orleans Hornets Payroll

    $76,132,192
    Cap Room

    -$18,432,192
    Player
    Salary
    PER Being Traded To

    T. McGrady$22,843,124$22.8M 16.4
    SG2 0 1 Year

    Being Traded To Toronto Raptors

    C. Budinger$725,000$725.0K N/A
    SF5 0 3 Years

    Acquiring 2 Players
    $23,568,124$23.6M
    New Orleans Hornets Roster

    Being Traded To H. Armstrong$2,801,198$2.8M 10.7C9 0 1 Year Being Traded To Bobby Brown$736,420$736.4K 8.9PG1 0 1 Year No Reacquiring (Minnesota Timberwolves)Restriction Expires: July 01, 2010Teams cannot reacquire a player that they traded during a given season (July 1 - June 30) unless the player has been waived.
    Being Traded To Devin Brown$1,107,572$1.1M 9.7SG2 0 1 Year Being Traded To D. Collison$1,266,120$1.2M N/AG3 0 2 Years Being Traded To Ike Diogu$825,497$825.4K 20.4PF6 0 1 Year Free AgentRestriction Expires: December 15, 2009After a free agent signs with a team, he cannot be traded for 3 months or until December 15, whichever is later.
    Being Traded To Sean Marks$825,497$825.4K 8.8PF6 0 1 Year Free AgentRestriction Expires: December 15, 2009After a free agent signs with a team, he cannot be traded for 3 months or until December 15, whichever is later.
    1-Year BirdRestriction Expires: July 01, 2010Must receive consent to trade players with a 1-year contract, excluding options, who will become Early Bird or Bird free agents at the end of the contract, or players who have accepted a qualifying offer for a 5th season following the 4th option season on the Rookie Scale. If the player consents, he will lose his Bird rights and become a non-Bird free agent at the end of the contract.
    Being Traded To Toronto Raptors Emeka Okafor$10,797,500$10.7M 18.0C9 0 5 Years No Reacquiring (Charlotte Bobcats)Restriction Expires: July 01, 2010Teams cannot reacquire a player that they traded during a given season (July 1 - June 30) unless the player has been waived.
    Being Traded To Chris Paul$13,520,500$13.5M 30.0PG1 0 3 Years Base Year Compensation (BYC)BYC Expires: July 01, 2010
    Outgoing Trade Value: $6,760,250If a team is over the Salary Cap and enters into a new player contract with a Bird or Early Bird free agent or an extension of a Rookie Scale Contract, that provides for a salary in the first year of the contract in excess of 120% of the player's salary in the prior season, the player will be subject to a Base Year Compensation. If such a player is traded, his Base Year Compensation will be used instead of his salary for purposes of determining the amount of his Traded Player Exception. The player's Base Year Compensation will equal the greater of the salary for the last season of his preceding Contract, or 50% of the player's then-current salary.
    Being Traded To M. Peterson$5,800,000$5.8M 10.7SG2 0 2 Years Being Traded To James Posey$6,031,800$6.0M 10.9SF5 0 3 Years Being Traded To D. Songaila$4,526,000$4.5M 13.9FC8 0 2 Years No Reacquiring (Minnesota Timberwolves)Restriction Expires: July 01, 2010Teams cannot reacquire a player that they traded during a given season (July 1 - June 30) unless the player has been waived.
    Being Traded To Houston Rockets P. Stojakovic$13,392,000$13.3M 12.5SF5 0 2 Years Being Traded To M. Thornton$457,588$457.5K N/AG3 0 2 Years Being Traded To David West$9,075,000$9.0M 19.0PF6 0 3 Years Being Traded To J. Wright$2,000,040$2.0M 12.7SF5 0 2 Years
    Trade Exceptions

    R. Butler$4,045,000$4.0M T. Chandler$902,500$902.5K A. Daniels$2,074,000$2.0M
    Hollinger's Analysis: -6 Wins

    With this trade you have decreased this team's projected wins by 6.
    Toronto Raptors Payroll

    $68,969,475
    Cap Room

    -$11,269,475
    Player
    Salary
    PER Being Traded To

    Emeka Okafor$10,797,500$10.7M 18.0
    C9 0 5 Years

    Being Traded To New Orleans Hornets

    Luis Scola$3,284,667$3.2M 17.1
    PF6 0 1 Year

    Acquiring 2 Players
    $14,082,167$14.1M
    Toronto Raptors Roster

    Being Traded To Marcus Banks$4,553,793$4.5M 7.8PG1 0 2 Years Being Traded To A. Bargnani$6,527,491$6.5M 14.7FC8 0 6 Years Poison Pill Provision (PPP)PPP Expires: July 01, 2010
    Outgoing Trade Value: $6,527,491A player who signs an extension that is to begin the following season has what's known as a "poison pill" contract. He can no longer be traded for a player making equal money. Instead, his current salary is averaged along with the salaries he is to receive in his extension, and that average becomes his incoming salary for trade purposes.
    Being Traded To M. Belinelli$1,547,640$1.5M 11.9SG2 0 2 Years No Reacquiring (Golden State Warriors)Restriction Expires: July 01, 2010Teams cannot reacquire a player that they traded during a given season (July 1 - June 30) unless the player has been waived.
    Being Traded To Houston Rockets Chris Bosh$15,779,912$15.7M 22.2PF6 0 1 Year Being Traded To J. Calderon$8,219,009$8.2M 18.8PG1 0 4 Years Being Traded To D. DeRozan$2,282,640$2.2M N/AF7 0 2 Years Being Traded To Reggie Evans$4,960,000$4.9M 10.4PF6 0 2 Years Being Traded To Jarrett Jack$5,000,000$5.0M 13.1G3 0 4 Years Free AgentRestriction Expires: December 15, 2009After a free agent signs with a team, he cannot be traded for 3 months or until December 15, whichever is later.
    Being Traded To Amir Johnson$3,941,667$3.9M 13.6PF6 0 1 Year No Reacquiring (Milwaukee Bucks)Restriction Expires: July 01, 2010Teams cannot reacquire a player that they traded during a given season (July 1 - June 30) unless the player has been waived.
    Being Traded To P. Mensah-Bonsu$825,497$825.4K 14.5C9 0 1 Year Free AgentRestriction Expires: December 15, 2009After a free agent signs with a team, he cannot be traded for 3 months or until December 15, whichever is later.
    Being Traded To R. Nesterovic$1,990,000$1.9M 14.2C9 0 1 Year Free AgentRestriction Expires: December 15, 2009After a free agent signs with a team, he cannot be traded for 3 months or until December 15, whichever is later.
    Being Traded To P. O'Bryant$855,189$855.1K 11.9C9 0 1 Year Being Traded To H. Turkoglu$9,000,000$9.0M 14.8SF5 0 5 Years Free AgentRestriction Expires: December 15, 2009After a free agent signs with a team, he cannot be traded for 3 months or until December 15, whichever is later.
    Being Traded To Sonny Weems$736,420$736.4K N/ASG2 0 2 Years No Reacquiring (Denver Nuggets)Restriction Expires: July 01, 2010Teams cannot reacquire a player that they traded during a given season (July 1 - June 30) unless the player has been waived.
    No Reacquiring (Milwaukee Bucks)Restriction Expires: July 01, 2010Teams cannot reacquire a player that they traded during a given season (July 1 - June 30) unless the player has been waived.
    Being Traded To A. Wright$1,800,000$1.8M 8.6SF5 0 1 Year No Reacquiring (Dallas Mavericks)Restriction Expires: July 01, 2010Teams cannot reacquire a player that they traded during a given season (July 1 - June 30) unless the player has been waived.

    Trade Exceptions

    J. Kapono$1,144,480$1.1M J. Moon$711,517$711.5K W. Solomon$722,517$722.5K
    Hollinger's Analysis: -10 Wins

    With this trade you have decreased this team's projected wins by 10.
     
  10. mustang98

    mustang98 Member

    Joined:
    Feb 17, 2009
    Messages:
    67
    Likes Received:
    53
    Sorry about that guys. It didn't come out the way i meant it to. Here's the breakdown.

    Rockets Outgoing:
    Tracy McGrady
    Chase Dudinger
    Luis Scola

    Rockets Incoming:
    Chris Bosh
    Peja Stojakovic

    New Olreans Outgoing:
    Omeka Okufor
    Peja Stojakovic

    New Orleans Incoming:
    Tracy McGrady
    Chase Budinger

    Toronto Outgoing:
    Chris Bosh

    Toronto Incoming:
    Omeka Okufor
    Luis Scola

    According the Trade Machine this trade will give us an 11 win improvement over the current roster. I know Peja is no longer that good of a player plus he has a large contract but let's be realistic, the Rockets will have to get back a bad contract because of the size of McGrady's contract. I think both Toronto and New Orleans would bite, not too sure about the Rockets because of Stojakovic's contract.
     
  11. jopatmc

    jopatmc Member

    Joined:
    Sep 4, 2002
    Messages:
    15,370
    Likes Received:
    390

    Not trying to trade Landry. Would prefer to trade Scola. But reality is Landry has more trade value than Scola right now and that is who teams are going to ask for. Landry is younger, and he is more efficient. Scola is a pending free agent, fixing to get a salary of between $25 mill to $40 over 4-5 years. Landry has another year left at $3 million before he becomes a free agent. Landry is the better value and is the player that teams are going to ask for.
     
  12. jopatmc

    jopatmc Member

    Joined:
    Sep 4, 2002
    Messages:
    15,370
    Likes Received:
    390


    1. He is taller, has more range, and is a better defender than either one. Landry is a terrible defender. Scola is an average defender. Neither one of them can shoot from 3.

    2. Pros-He spreads the floor better than either Scola/Landry. He can dribble drive and finish above the rim, something Landry can do near the basket, and something Scola does below the basket. Bosh can drive it in from the perimeter and slam it down without drawing the offensive foul. Also, he is rangier, when Yao is on the bench, he can be the fast 5 that runs with the 2nd unit.

    3. Kareem/Worthy(pretty close to Yao/Bosh); Bird/McHale/Parish.

    4. Our greatest weakness is a legit big man that can both score and be a defensive presence in the paint.
     
  13. wekko368

    wekko368 Member

    Joined:
    Jan 3, 2008
    Messages:
    8,915
    Likes Received:
    1,028
    I'm curious as to why you think Scola is only an average defender. Secondly, I'd rather my PF try to get offensive rebounds as opposed to hanging around the 3 pt line. Thirdly, he shot 24.5% from the 3 pt line last year. That's not very good.

    No cons? How about the fact that if he plays alongside Yao, both their production will go down, especially Bosh's. If Yao starts playing limited (~30) mpg, it makes sense for the Rockets to milk him for those 30 min.

    Also, I want to point out that in the past 2 seasons, Bosh did not shoot above 50% from the field which is something Scola did in both seasons.

    Furthermore, Scola has proven that he's capable of playing the running game as well.

    Yes, these were successful teams, but in your honest opinion, are these examples relevant? Do we have one of the best centers of all time? Do we have the best PG of all time? Do we have the best SF of all time?

    And he'll be back next year. Bringing in a serviceable backup center (along the lines of a Gortat-type player) will improve this team far more than trading for Bosh.
     
  14. A_3PO

    A_3PO Member

    Joined:
    Apr 29, 2006
    Messages:
    46,754
    Likes Received:
    12,299
    You guys that are against pursuing Bosh, what do you suggest the Rockets do to get better? Name other players they should go after. Don't bother bringing up LeBron or Wade. Don't say you want them to tank this season and try to draft John Wall. Don't tell me Yao's return will solve everything because it won't.

    I'd like to know if you have a better plan.
     
  15. wekko368

    wekko368 Member

    Joined:
    Jan 3, 2008
    Messages:
    8,915
    Likes Received:
    1,028
    First of all, there's nothing wrong with tanking to acquire a potential franchise player.

    Secondly, we shouldn't make a move (i.e. acquiring Bosh) just for the sake of making a move.

    Kevin Martin? Joe Johnson? A serviceable backup C?
     
  16. worzel gummidge

    Joined:
    Sep 30, 2008
    Messages:
    6,533
    Likes Received:
    150
    If the Rockets can't pry Lopez away from the Nets...
    [​IMG]
     
  17. A_3PO

    A_3PO Member

    Joined:
    Apr 29, 2006
    Messages:
    46,754
    Likes Received:
    12,299
    How does tanking allow the Rockets to acquire a franchise player? Explain that one to me. Of the boatload of teams that have tanked the last 10 years, how many of them got a franchise player because they tanked the season? Very very few.

    Nobody is saying make a move for the sake of making a move. Bosh isn't a franchise player like the Big 3, but is injury-prone Kevin Martin? No. Is Joe Johnson? No. JJ turned down 5yrs/$80MM from the Hawks. Is he worth more than that to the Rockets? But at least I can accept that JJ might be a better option than Bosh.

    Agree with you on the backup C, but the Rockets need a lot more than that. They need a dynamic/versatile swing player that can score when the going gets tough. The wheels come off the motion offense when good defensive teams tighten the screws because nobody can dribble except Brooks and/or Lowry.
     
  18. jopatmc

    jopatmc Member

    Joined:
    Sep 4, 2002
    Messages:
    15,370
    Likes Received:
    390
    Here's the questions. What players are going to potentially be available that we can trade for that would be better than Bosh or Chris Paul? I don't see them.

    Amare may have been available if PHX imploded to start the season but they are in playoff mode. Dont' see him being available and don't think he's better than Bosh anyways.

    Washington is likely wanting to blow out Arenas and possibly Jamison/Caron, etc. since they stink so bad. But are any of those guys better than Chris Bosh? I don't see it.

    Memphis has no one. They're looking to blow out Zach and Jaric for expirings/young talent/draft picks if they can. Are they going to give up Mayo just to get rid of Zach/Marko? Nope.

    Indy? Are they going to move Granger with Dunleavy/Murphy...and is Granger better than Bosh or Paul? Nope.

    Clippers.....Bardon Davis/Chris Kaman...not better than Bosh. The rookie from Oklahoma....they're not trading him.

    GS.....Monta/Biedrins/Maggette....better than Bosh...............fail.

    Knicks......nothing

    Nets.....nothing

    The short list of players that would potentially be better than Bosh.....

    Kobe
    Lebron
    DWade
    Dwight
    Chris Paul
    Brandon Roy
    Melo
    Deron Williams
    Garnett
    Duncan


    Now there may be some as good as Bosh, the questionables
    Amare
    Gilbert
    Rondo
    Pao
    etc etc etc

    So, the point is....if the rumor is true that there may be a player available that is better than Chris Bosh........there's not too many players that we could be talking about. I believe that rumor (stupid me). I think the player that may be available is Chris Paul. When you look at the list of players that are better, not too many of them are going to be available. When you look at the list of players that MAY be as good as Bosh...not too many of them are going to be available.

    Next point: IF you cannot see that Bosh is a significant upgrade and a top 15 player in the league, then I don't have anything to say to you. If you continue to try to make the argument that he is not a significant upgrade over Scola/Landry.....then you are probably the same person that doesn't believe that Chris Paul would be a significant upgrade over Brooks/Lowry. I like all 4 players....Scola/Landry/Brooks/Lowry........A LOT! But I would trade some combination of them for either Bosh or Paul in a heartbeat!
     
  19. baller4life315

    Joined:
    Sep 2, 2003
    Messages:
    12,703
    Likes Received:
    3,036
    Agreed completely which is why the reluctance to play McGrady is so perplexing. But anyway.....
     
  20. jopatmc

    jopatmc Member

    Joined:
    Sep 4, 2002
    Messages:
    15,370
    Likes Received:
    390


    That need disappates when you have a point like Chris Paul that can get his shot anytime he wants it and can get anybody else practically any shot they want.
     

Share This Page