Dilfer vs. Marino is interesting. Doug Williams is another. QBs are different than any other position. The SB wins are more important to their legacy. I think I would take the SB win over Jim Kelly. I mention Ward just because the difference is so close. Championship vs. HOF question depends on the non-HOF career. Even Branch has a SB MVP, but he obviously hasn't had a great career. Easier decision if you are just outside the HOF, and you won titles than if you were just an average role player or bench player.
