I forgot about this place. It's damn good. Thing is, there are 2 different Joe's Pizza places in Sheridan Square (almost next to each other). I've been to the one on the corner (walked in randomly). I was pleasantly surprised. I personally think Patsy's is blah. I've been to the one in Murray Hill and the one on University, and I didn't think they were anything special. Nothing beats a plain cheese slice from Arturo's...
the jazz at Arturo's isn't bad either. of course the CORNER Joe's is better I've never tried the other Patsy's , but it's good to have a trustworthy Slice in any neighborhood, eh?