Now way in heck. Reggie is a HoF and just retired plus was rumored to maybe comeback this year. I read a story in the Indy Star just a month or two ago and he said he still practices everyday and is close to game shape. all the ESPN guys were scrubs when the played except Mark Jackson and Mashburn. An out of shape Magic and Barkley are just as good as an in-shape Legler or any other ESPN guy. The only ESPN guy who might dominate is Mashburn and that's because he retired recently and wasn't a scrub.
I'm hoping you just overlooked Bill Walton... either way Reggie is the only one in decent shape on the TNT squad. The only one that looks to be in bad shape on the ESPN squad is Walton. Didn't you see Barkley barely out run Dick Baveta? He, Kenny, and Magic wouldn't be able to do much. I think it would be pretty much lopsided cause the ESPN guys have more people who are in shape. Tim Legler, Greg Anthony, Jalen Rose, and Mashburn look the same as they did when they played. Those HOFers would get ran ragged.