I personally would take Hurts over Herbert.. I'm not a big Josh Allen fan but I recognize why folks love him. Herbert career failures ,thus far isn't all on him , whatsoever .. The team can't get out of its own way whether it's injuries or stupidity from the coaches.. But it seems to be something missing with him.. Burrow is just flat out a stud and of course Mahomes is Mahomes.. I'd put Hurts 4th behind Mahomes, Burrow, and Allen tho IMO.. I'm still an ARod believer though so he may be 5th lol ..