Welcome! Please take a few seconds to create your free account to post threads, make some friends, remove a few ads while surfing and much more. ClutchFans has been bringing fans together to talk Houston Sports since 1996. Join us!

"Wuz?" Has this reporter lost it?

Discussion in 'BBS Hangout' started by Rocket G, Aug 18, 2008.

Page 1 of 2

Rocket G Contributing Member

Joined:

Jun 23, 2004

Messages:

1,623

Likes Received:

8

Or is he just an idiot?

LINK

He uses "wuz" not once, but twice. How does this make it past an editor?

#1 Rocket G, Aug 18, 2008

Jimes Member

Joined:

Mar 28, 2006

Messages:

868

Likes Received:

27

Tough math leaves Liukin silver
By Alan Abrahamson
Posted Monday, August 18, 2008 5:29 AM ET
United States' Nastia Liukin (L) looks on as she stands on the podium with China's He Kexin (C) and China's Yang Yilin (R).
FRANCK FIFE/Getty Images
United States' Nastia Liukin (L) looks on as she stands on the podium with China's He Kexin (C) and China's Yang Yilin (R).

BEIJING -- Nastia Liukin tied for first but got second in an incredibly convoluted scoring mess in the women's uneven bars competition Mondaya at the 2008 Beijing Olympics.

It seemed she wuz robbed, China's He Kexin geting the gold, Liukin left with silver. China's Yang Yilin got the bronze, the bars results adding to the host nation's sensational gymnastics performance at these Games -- the great haul of China.

Wuz Liukin robbed?

No, at least not mathematically.

But that didn't do anything to lessen the sting of getting the exact same score, 16.725, but getting silver instead of gold.

"It's nothing I can control," Liukin said. "It's all up to the judges.

"I'm definitely a little upset. You know, I was hoping I could get another gold," to go with the individual all-around gold she won last Friday.

She also won bronze in the floor exercise and a team silver. She and Shawn Johnson, who has three silvers, compete Tuesday night on the beam -- their final event.

"... You know," Liukin said, "a fourth Olympic medal -- I have to be happy."

Steve Penny, the president of USA Gymnastics, said the Americans would not file a protest. "We agree with it," he said. "It's done. We're moving on."

Martha Karolyi, the U.S. women's head coach at these Games, would say only, "I'm not saying anything."

Her husband of 43 years, Bela Karolyi, the legendary gymnastics coach who at these Games is also serving as an adviser to NBC, was hardly so reticent.

"That makes no sense," he said, adding, "They're saying they improved the scoring system. Look at this."
Photos

* EF: Uneven Bars
EF: Uneven Bars

Gallery from the dramatic uneven bars final.
* Liukin: Beijing
* Nastia Liukin: through the years

Gymnastics' new code of points went into effect after judging controversies rocked the Athens 2004 Games. The new code was ratified in late 2005 and was first implemented in 2006.

A complete score is now made up of two parts, A and B.

The first, the A score, or the start value, is an assigned degree of difficulty.

In this instance, both He and Liukin had the same start value, 7.7.

The second part of a score, the B score, is an execution score.

Six judges vote.

The high and the low are tossed per the rules.

That leaves four scores.

Those four are averaged.

That average becomes the B score.

Add the A and B together and you get a complete score.

In this instance, both He and Liukin got 16.725.

Thus: onto tiebreakers.

The first tiebreak is the B score.

Here both got the same B score, 9.025.

The next tiebreak: the judges drop the next highest deduction.

That obviously leaves three judges' scores instead of four -- or to be precise, the marks those three judges gave for deductions.

Here, the average of those three judges' deductions for He: .933.

For Liukin: .966.

Liukin had a greater deduction.

Thus she was second.

Another way of getting to that math: Take the B scores of the three judges from that second tie-break, add them together and divide by three.

The math for He: 9.1, 9.1, 9.0. That equals 27.2. Divide that by three, and that equals 9.066, the sixes stretching out to infinity.

For Liukin: 9.1, 9.0, 9.0. That equals 27.1. Divide that by three and it's 9.0333, the threes going out forever.

Thus she was second.
Which, all the same, didn't make it any easier. Because even if the math is right, it's logically still just naturally tough to get.

"Seeing the exact same score and 'second' next to my name," Liukin said, "made it a little bit harder."
Click to expand...

Lol, great find! That is awesome.

#2 Jimes, Aug 18, 2008
BmwM3 Contributing Member

Joined:

May 19, 2002

Messages:

3,896

Likes Received:

255

1: How the heck did this guy become a writer?
2: Don't they proof read?
3: What the hell wuz they thinking hiring him?

#3 BmwM3, Aug 18, 2008
Butterfingers Contributing Member

Joined:

Aug 20, 2007

Messages:

1,841

Likes Received:

114

I can understand him using "u" instead of typing out "you." But wuz is three letters just like "was." lol so i dont get why he went out of his way to change the spelling when it doesnt shorten anything, you might as well spell it right.

#4 Butterfingers, Aug 18, 2008
namo Member

Joined:

Oct 11, 2007

Messages:

166

Likes Received:

0

"NBC Sports contributor Alan Abrahamson brings a wealth of knowledge to his coverage of the Olympics and the sports world."

#5 namo, Aug 18, 2008
Major Malcontent Contributing Member

Joined:

Dec 18, 2000

Messages:

3,177

Likes Received:

211

"We wuz robbed" is an expression like "Ya gotta believe".

I question the wisdom of using it in a formal article, but I have no doubt it was intentional.

#6 Major Malcontent, Aug 18, 2008
SuperBeeKay Member

Joined:

Feb 24, 2008

Messages:

6,185

Likes Received:

258

he wuz hi wen he wuz writin it

#7 SuperBeeKay, Aug 18, 2008

meggoleggo Contributing Member

Joined:

Aug 21, 2003

Messages:

4,402

Likes Received:

48

Since when did Mondaya become a day of the week?

BEIJING -- Nastia Liukin tied for first but got second in an incredibly convoluted scoring mess in the women's uneven bars competition Mondaya at the 2008 Beijing Olympics.
Click to expand...

#8 meggoleggo, Aug 18, 2008
s land balla Contributing Member

Joined:

Apr 24, 2001

Messages:

6,608

Likes Received:

365

Who cares??

#9 s land balla, Aug 18, 2008
SwoLy-D Contributing Member

Joined:

Jul 20, 2001

Messages:

37,617

Likes Received:

1,448

Nice catch, Ms. Meggo.

Maybe his ex-wife drives this:

#10 SwoLy-D, Aug 18, 2008
shaaz w Member

Joined:

Jul 14, 2003

Messages:

124

Likes Received:

7

He also typed "Mondaya" !!!!
Does he not use spell check?

#11 shaaz w, Aug 18, 2008
Zboy Contributing Member

Joined:

Aug 19, 2002

Messages:

27,234

Likes Received:

21,956

shaaz w said:

He also typed "Mondaya" !!!!
Does he not use spell check?
Click to expand...

I have a feeling he got the wrong version.

#12 Zboy, Aug 18, 2008
TMac640 Contributing Member

Joined:

Jan 10, 2005

Messages:

5,484

Likes Received:

1

sLaNd B a L L a said:

Who cares??
Click to expand...

Which is why morons would get away with being illiterate and incompetent

#13 TMac640, Aug 18, 2008

Astro101 Member

Joined:

Jul 1, 2002

Messages:

2,068

Likes Received:

2

AH dammit. I was gonna watch on tape delay later tonight. ARgh.

#14 Astro101, Aug 18, 2008
playlife Member

Joined:

Jun 29, 2006

Messages:

1,267

Likes Received:

25

It seemed she wuz robbed, China's He Kexin geting the gold, Liukin left with silver. China's Yang Yilin got the bronze, the bars results adding to the host nation's sensational gymnastics performance at these Games -- the great haul of China.
Click to expand...

We can have a game of who finds a spelling error.

#15 playlife, Aug 18, 2008
Major Malcontent Contributing Member

Joined:

Dec 18, 2000

Messages:

3,177

Likes Received:

211

I reverse my earlier position. He is an idiot and his editor should be canned.

#16 Major Malcontent, Aug 18, 2008
KingCheetah Contributing Member

Joined:

Jun 3, 2002

Messages:

56,376

Likes Received:

48,317

Wut !?

#17 KingCheetah, Aug 18, 2008
Kyakko Contributing Member

Joined:

Aug 15, 2002

Messages:

2,161

Likes Received:

39

Major Malcontent said:

I reverse my earlier position. He is an idiot and his editor should be canned.
Click to expand...

flip flopper

#18 Kyakko, Aug 18, 2008

Hayesfan Contributing Member

Joined:

Nov 3, 2006

Messages:

10,900

Likes Received:

360

Major Malcontent said:

I reverse my earlier position. He is an idiot and his editor should be canned.
Click to expand...

Agreed. x2!

Edit: The guilty party...

http://blogs.nbcsports.com/home/archives/alan_abrahamson/

#19 Hayesfan, Aug 18, 2008
Jeff Clutch Crew

Joined:

Feb 14, 1999

Messages:

22,412

Likes Received:

362

Major Malcontent said:

"We wuz robbed" is an expression like "Ya gotta believe".

I question the wisdom of using it in a formal article, but I have no doubt it was intentional.
Click to expand...

I can see you using it ONCE, but TWICE? That just seems like overkill or stupidity. Nevermind the subjectivity of the phrase.

#20 Jeff, Aug 18, 2008

(You must log in or sign up to post here.)

Page 1 of 2

Share This Page