Official "Should I" Thread

^oh yeah and Matthews and Bush

 

I would hate benching Andre Johnson against Denver--that could be a high scoring game. But if ppr Edelman is definitely the safer option.

Definitely Cutler at QB.

I'm not a fan of Arizona or SD as defenses this week. Can you pick up Detroit or Cleveland? I like Detroit against Eli without Cruz or Nicks. And Cleveland against the Jets is a good pick since everyone does good against the Jets. Denver's D against Houston would be my 3rd choice.

 

Delanie Walker VS jaguars
or
Greg Olsen vs NO

Thank you in advance folks.

 

Should I start Johnson over Rainey or Edelman? I'm thinking probably not, but it's a close call.

QB Colin Kaepernick
RB Eddie Lacy
RB Bobby Rainey (@STL)
WR Jordy Nelson
WR Josh Gordon
TE Jimmy Graham
FLEX Julian Edelman (@BAL)
D/ST Browns D/ST
K Steven Hauschka

Bench:
Dennis Johnson, Hou RB (v. Den)

 

Matt Ryan (vs 49ers) or Andy Dalton?
Andre Johnson or Jordy Nelson?
Julius thomas or amendola?

 

or who gets the start? cousins, ryan, or dalton?

 

I'd go Dalton, Johnson and Thomas (Nelson is a better option and Thomas though).

 

drop matt ryan. those 5 yd passes he throws all game dont result in many TDs. Dalton by a mile...

 

cousins or dalton?

 

If it is PPR keep edelman in. and that lineup should be fine. With Schaub back i dont think he will hand off the ball as much as people would think. Sensing that he would be fighting for his job position back.. maybe.

 

This is a coin flip, but i will go with dalton since he has better weapons.

 

You're probably fine either way, but I'd go Delanie Walker. I like the matchup against the Jaguars. Walker had a good game against them earlier this year(4/62/1). Olsen had (8/40/0) against the Saints in New Orleans.

So Olsen is the safer option, but Walker has the better chance to have a big game.

 

Thank you boss. Yeah i am start Ryan Fitzpatrick over Russell Wilson, so i was wondering if i should just start olsen. but after this i am for sure starting walker.

 

Thanks...I'll look at those defenses.

It's PPR. AJ will have a nice game with Schaub returning but it'll be just catches and yards. Edelman is a bigger scoring threat.

Cutler over Cousins? Decisions!

 

Thanks to you also. Guess it'll be Cutler

 

Serious here:
Brees @ Car (#1 QB Def)
Dalton vs Min (#2 QB Off)

 

Believe it or not, Dalton is the safer pick here. Since week 6, the only quarterback that has scored fewer than 18 points against the Vikings is Eli Manning.

Brees on the other hand has a well established pattern of sucking on the road versus good defenses in open air stadiums. Of course he could go off, but depends on how desperate you are.

 

You probably can't go wrong with this decision, but I'd go with Cutler.

 

Ok guys could use your input, Kapernick at home against Atlanta, Cutler against the Eagles or Andy Dalton against Vikings?

Also, in my flex position, I can go either Rashad Jennings against Chargers or Crabtree vs Atlanta or Jordan Todman vs Ten (assuming MJD misses again). This is a .5 ppr.

 

Dalton and Todman if MJD is out.