Official "Should I" Thread

Fun article. I got Antonio Brown for Vick (article is about Vick) and was satisfied with it.

 

Got Steven Jackson out... should I start Montee Ball or Benjarvus Green-Ellis?

 

Personally, I would start Green-Ellis for the sole purpose of keeping his trade value up. Benched players tend to be devalued... so play him, hope he has a nice game, and trade him next week. That would be my plan, haha

 

I'd go BGE.

Peyton loss Clady, more Knowshon time.

 

Its a fair deal. Depends on what the rest of your team looks like.

 

I accepted it and bowe just put up a big nothing

I think I am okay cause I prefer Brady to luck but kinda wish I had taken Austin

 

Thomas is a stud, but I'd rather have Cruz. Hands down, best option in NY. Thomas might be better than Welker, Decker, and Thomas, but the point is Denver has too many options.

 

Good point.

 

Well a lopsided trade has been accepted in my 12 team ppr leauge. Cj spiller for deandre hopkins straight up. I hate that trade, but looking for any pros for this trade to even happen. $25 entry league, smalll money but it looks so lopsided. Feedback welcomed. BTW hopkins is a bench player for the cj spiller reciepient team.

 

That would be vetoed in any other league.

 

Pick 2 out of the rest to put in my second RB and Flex spot. I have Spiller which is an auto start.

McFadden vs Denver
Lamar Miller vs Atlanta
Moreno vs Oakland

I have been leaning putting in McFadden and Moreno

Thoughts?

 

Hmm. Tough one. PPR?

I think you made the right call either way.

 

Not a PPR league.

 

Would any of you guys accept this trade?

David Wilson
Andre Johnson

For

Eric Decker
Daryl Richardson

?

 

Veto. NOW.

 

PPR? Heck yes. Johnson is the best player and most consistent in the deal. Decker, who knows how he will perform week to week.

Richardson who I believed in has his arrow pointing down. I'd say Wilson has a much, much higher ceiling but either one could easily wind up as the backup on their own team. I think if Richardson performs this week all is well but if he looks mediocre and is hobbled by that injury and Pead continues to steal snaps he's in trouble.

 

Moreno for sure.

Guess I'll go McFadden based on him playing more snaps. But DEN has been good against the run in the first two games based on yardage.

Game could be 28-3 by halftime and DEN goes into prevent mode, possibly more check downs to McFadden.

 

2 leagues...

Should I start Reggie Wayne or E. Royal?

Also, Reggie Wayne or G. Bernard?

Yes, I do have R. Wayne in both of my leagues lol.

 

Thanks for the feedback I vetoed that trade yesterday, but majority rules. Hopefully the commissioner halts this trade.

 

lol damn, I hate playing players on Thursday also but I just like watching and rooting for them. I'm going to sit them from now on Thursdays.