More Impressive List: Derek Jeter or John Mayer?

Jeter easily.

 

I think you forgot Jessica simpson off Mayers list and I believe it was when she was smoking hot. Maybe dukes of hazard era.

Still Jeter absolutely owns him with that list.
Fez is a pretty close second, especially since he also got Alba and nailed a prime Lohan.

 

He has Simpson on his list.

 

I see plenty. Sure I'll saddle her up and take a ride from behind but if she wants to change positions I'll have to say "NEIGH" :grin:

 

Gotta go with Jeter.

 

A horse a horse, of course of course

 

The Thadeus is so Alpha that he did Jeter. Therefore you have to combine Jeter and Thadeus's votes.

 

Even Stephen A. Smith recognizes the beauty in the Jeter's roster.