Forget About Age and Health - T-Mac vs. LeBron - Who's the better player?

i think bron would dominate the mavs dude. wade would have struggled v. this D too since his J is just as bad. they would have gien wade tons of space to operate. but wade has shaq.

i can never imagine tmac/kobe be given 5ft to operate. not in any situation

 

Yet another dumb poll. Forget age and health??? Then you better take away TMacs experience as well. Take out his experience and then you have to also size up who they've played against, divisions that they've played in, how were the teams TMac was on constructed and what schemes did they run...go on and on.

 

It's mac. lebron is awesom, but mac i a better overall player.

 

forget about health and age, then playoff success determines who's better which goes to lebron james

 

I think if you were to compare the two...

I would say Tmac has had a more successful career then Lebron... thus far...

even if Lebron has gone farther in the Playoffs

I think Tmac in his Hey day was a better all around player... compared to Lebron in his 4 years....

Lebron...is more athletic...and I think still has maturing to do and hasnt hit his peak yet... and

 

nah man bron has a better career. a finals apperance at 22?

damn.

 

Winning the Little Dribbler Confrence doesn't carry much weight. At best they were the 5th or 6th best team in the league.

 

man you are crazy. wades midrange J is delicious. i agree t-mac would have performed much better against the spurs, but i think lebron would have performed better against the jazz.

 

Lebron forever !!

 

Lebron. Is this even a question.

I loved Tmac. But Lebron is a tier above.

 

Lebron only fan spotted ...

 

This is a joke right?

Lebron is in the top 2 or 3 players of all time - and TMac might be in the hall of fame.

Tmac is not even close to Lebron.

DD

 

Tears of laughter that Tracy fans ever thought they were in the same league

 

Tmac has no chance.....

But if you play it 22 old Tmac vs 22 old Lebron it is a lot closer and Tmac could do some damage there.

 

Well, who is the better pitcher...

Tmac lol Go Skeeters!

 

Lebron is better 10X Tmac

 

Lock down this thread

 

Lol, I can't believe this was even a thread, rofl, Wtf Wtf?!?! T-Mac only got out of round 1 when he was on the bench for the Spurs, hahah. Obviously it wasn't necessarily always Mac's fault, but LeBron is special, one of the top players of all-time.

 

Yes, Lololol

 

The Tracy McGrady fans have always hated one thing

THE TRUTH

Hundreds of years from now, no basketball fan would ever link Tracy McGrady with LeBron James

they might think they were both human beings and that's about it