According to Brewer's father speaking with the Arkansas Democrat-Gazette: http://www.clutchfans.net/news/1318/brewers_dad_raves_about_rocket_workout/ They're wide open threes, so it's very good but it's not a "Turkcan Nachbar" ... a 25-25 type performance that makes the Rockets selecting him a lock. But for Brewer, where the knock is his shot, that's pretty sharp.
ha ha, the infamous shooting drill. I thought that was gone with Rudy and Joe Ash? (and boki, mirsad, collier (RIP) and Langhi, who all rode it to a payday). Guess not.
I'm sensing same hate (or dislike, at least) for Ronnie in this thread and I don't understand it. His weaknesses are no more of a red flag than those of any other player we'd take at #8. The bottom line is that the guy has size and athleticism, and he can play all three backcourt positions on offense and defense. The major knock on the guy is his shooting form, more so than his shooting percentages, which are actually beyond acceptable. So I have to ask...why wouldn't someone want this guy at #8?
I'll take him at 8 any time probably before redick, but if carney, roy or even bargnani are available I would not wait a second to pick one of them...
Personally, I feel this way... Roy > Brewer > Carney > Redick Unfortunately I'm not optimistic that Roy will fall to us, and there's no way on God's green earth that Bargnani is there at #8. I'll bet both my testicles on that.
Carney is a better shooter, far more athletic, and a better finisher. The same goes for Rudy Gay. Ronnie Brewer needs to dominate the ball to be at his best and will not be able to play PG in the NBA. His 3 point shooting was erratic and I still question his range even after a shooting drill that seemingly proves nothing. Call me a hater, but I think those first two guys are just better for the Rockets.
brewer is not a good shooter. don't let a guy standing there on the 3 point line with no defense and all the time in the world, fool you into thinking someone can shoot. it is a PRACTICE drill, not a game drill. however, i do like brewer for everything else he does. he reminds of a better ball-handling and passing josh howard. he can impact the game on both ends of the floor. obviously, we need some shooting but i really wouldn't be upset if we chose brewer over carney. brewer is more versatile and consistent.
I would just like to clarify that I'm not claiming Brewer to be a good shooter from this workout. I post on another message board where one of the few Rockets fans is also a University of Arkansas student and has basically seen Ronnie play every game for the past 3 years. You have to admit, that's probably more than anyone in the Rockets front office, and it's certainly more than the people running mock draft sites. That said, this poster gets very defensive when someone (myself included) brings up Ronnie's shooting (in)abilities. He says that people vastly over-emphasize that aspect of his game due to his form and that his shooting is NOT particularly bad at all. I don't know about you, but I'm inclined to believe he knows a little bit about the kid. Besides, compare Brewer's shooting %'s with Carney, if you will. If anything, it's Brewer who has been more impressive over the past couple of years, which is all I'm really concerned with since it's not uncommon for a player to take some time to adjust when forced to play big minutes as a freshman.
I don't think it's the effectiveness of his shot as much as the ugly form, which he can't do too much about given his elbow problem ... I'm sure scouts are asking how effective he will be getting his shot off in the pros. As far as defense goes, if you watch him in this highlight clip... http://www.clutchfans.net/nbadraft/profiles/2006/ronnie_brewer/?fuseaction=video&VideoID=7 ... you can see he has real long arms and could potentially become a real defensive gem, I would think.
That is very interesting news. I have never watched Brewer play but after reading his scouting report the only thing I didn't like was their comments about his shooting mechanics. I imagine I can get over that if he is consistent despite his flawed mechanics.