1. Welcome! Please take a few seconds to create your free account to post threads, make some friends, remove a few ads while surfing and much more. ClutchFans has been bringing fans together to talk Houston Sports since 1996. Join us!

What is Falun Gong and why is China cracking down on it?

Discussion in 'BBS Hangout' started by HayesStreet, Sep 7, 2002.

  1. HayesStreet

    HayesStreet Member

    Joined:
    Oct 1, 1999
    Messages:
    8,507
    Likes Received:
    181
    In a thread I started on the conflict between Islam and Western Civilization, one of our Chinese posters asked why I was not also questioning Falun Gong in China. I didn't want that thread to splinter into a different issue, but found the question interesting enough to take a look.

    "Falun Gong (also called Falun Dafa) is a traditional Chinese mind and body practice that combines meditation, gentle exercise, and moral teachings. At its core are the three principles of Truth, Compassion, and Tolerance. Those who practice Falun Gong do so to become better, healthier persons through living by these principles. Falun Gong shares some characteristics with Buddhism and Taoism, but is independent of these traditions.

    Falun Gong was introduced to the general public in 1992 in northeastern China by a government clerk named Li Hongzhi. The practice grew rapidly in size such that by 1999 a Chinese government survey estimated that between 70 and 100 million people were practicing in China. Today, Falun Gong is found in some 40 countries around the world. Practitioners are of every age, profession, and economic and educational background.

    Falun Gong has been recognized widely in the West for its health benefits and positive character. Particular support and recognition have come over the past two years while Falun Gong has been persecuted in China." (Quote from www.fofg.org)

    I thought maybe some of our posters with more insight into the day to day workings in the PRC can tell us why members of this group are being tortured and jailed.
     
    #1 HayesStreet, Sep 7, 2002
    Last edited by a moderator: Sep 7, 2002
  2. Jeff

    Jeff Clutch Crew

    Joined:
    Feb 14, 1999
    Messages:
    22,412
    Likes Received:
    362
    It has been targeted in China, like Buddhism in Tibet, because of the communist governments desire to squash religious practices that could undermine their authority.

    China, a couple years back, was highly embarrassed when a teen ager who is supposed to be the re-incarnation of a very highly-respected lama in the Buddhist religion was smuggled out of the country when it appeared China was going to imprison him.

    There was even talk that they wanted to capture and forcibly coerce him into telling Buddhists that the communist government was a good thing.

    Like any communist regime, they consider any organized independant organization or religion a threat to their authority.

    I know you can't see it from where you're located, but if anyone wants to see the Falun Gong practitioners in action, drive by the Chinese consulate on Montrose between Westheimer and Richmond. A large group of practitioners sits outside the consulate, meditates, chants and does exercises every day on the public right-of-way and sidewalk.
     
  3. 111chase111

    111chase111 Member

    Joined:
    Oct 16, 2000
    Messages:
    1,660
    Likes Received:
    21
    Actually, religion is not <i>officially</i> repressed in China. There are Catholic, Protestant and Muslim churches/mosques that operate (more of less) freely in China with no restrictions from the government. I was recently in China and we saw (incidentaly) a Catholic church and went to a Muslim market.

    Falun Gong is NOT a religion. It is more about a a way of living then worship of a deity. The problem is that there are a lot of members and the group has a huge influence on the way the members think. Plus the fact that the "group has taken to interrupting television broadcasts and beaming their own message into the homes of Chinese viewers." CNN Asia Website. This obviously upsets the government.

    The government also claims that the group is harmfull to its members as they may choose not to seek appropriate health care, instead relying on the practice for cures. However, I think that's just a government excuse. They are really upset over the political influence the organization has over its followers.

    I don't think the Chinese government has any issues with the <i>practice</i>, but with the fact the followers of the practice can be politically influenced by people other than the government.
     
  4. HayesStreet

    HayesStreet Member

    Joined:
    Oct 1, 1999
    Messages:
    8,507
    Likes Received:
    181
    Nice post.

    michecon says the CIA gives money to Falun Gong. Do we think that is a good thing?
     
  5. Deckard

    Deckard Blade Runner
    Supporting Member

    Joined:
    Mar 28, 2002
    Messages:
    57,800
    Likes Received:
    41,241
    How do we know that it's true, HayesStreet? The CIA probably gives money to high Communist Party officials in China... but how would we know THAT is true?
     
  6. Panda

    Panda Member

    Joined:
    Jun 5, 2002
    Messages:
    4,130
    Likes Received:
    1
    I thought CIA gave money to Saddam Hussein and Bin Laden as well?!
     
  7. michecon

    michecon Member

    Joined:
    May 19, 2002
    Messages:
    4,983
    Likes Received:
    9
    HS:

    Before we can discuss this "religion", Please know there "religion" first. Not just some abstract excerpt from some website. But the real writings by Li Hongzhi, preferrablly in Chinese. Try to learn about the history of Mr Li as well. Then we can move on to how this guy enmass wealth in poor China by illegal means and moved to the US. Finally, how the things his organization is doing beyond the "religious" teaching.

    I have to say, there is elements of that practice inheritant of the old Chinese Taoism practice mixed with vague or twasted Budhism gists. Some people practice it just like any other mind-peacing breath practice by any other Qigong in China. Well, I can do that too if only I buy 10 books about qigong in China and with my previous knowledge with these religions. But, if you do thngs I suggest you do, you'll find this Fanlun Gong is far beyond that. If you think islamic is evil...
     
  8. HayesStreet

    HayesStreet Member

    Joined:
    Oct 1, 1999
    Messages:
    8,507
    Likes Received:
    181
    Is that relevant? No.
     
  9. HayesStreet

    HayesStreet Member

    Joined:
    Oct 1, 1999
    Messages:
    8,507
    Likes Received:
    181
    The point is 'do we support actions to help non-violent groups.'
     
  10. HayesStreet

    HayesStreet Member

    Joined:
    Oct 1, 1999
    Messages:
    8,507
    Likes Received:
    181
    If you have something about his background to post, then post it. And if your argument is that the rest of the world must speak and read Chinese to understand the Chinese crackdown, then you are either WRONG or there is little chance of the world understanding China. We seem to understand Taiwan.

    Good for you! Breathe michecon, breathe...

    I've got a better idea. I've already posted spelling out what I think Falun Gong is. If you think they're evil, then post why you think that. Stop hiding behind your usual 'oh this is too complex to go into here' answer.
     
  11. michecon

    michecon Member

    Joined:
    May 19, 2002
    Messages:
    4,983
    Likes Received:
    9


    You always amuse me HS, I have to say.

    Right! It's very easy to take a shot at the things you know essentially nothing and let others come up every proof to defend. I don't have a holl of time, but it's sunday, so...

    Here are some quotes from Li hongzhi's teaching (in English, so presumablly to a better educated audiance):

    In qigong practices that cultivate dan, it is very difficult for one to achieve the state of Unlocking Gong and enlightenment while among ordinary people. Our Falun Dafa does not cultivate dan. Our practice cultivates a Falun in the lower abdomen. I personally install it for practitioners in the class.

    We cultivate Falun instead of dan. Falun is a miniature of the universe that possesses all of the universe’s capabilities, and it can operate and rotate automatically.

    There are also people who ask me, "Why can it rotate? What’s the reason?" It is easy to understand that dan can form when energy accumulates, but it is inconceivable that Falun rotates. Let me give you an example. The universe is in motion, and all of the universe’s Milky Ways and galaxies are also in motion. The nine planets orbit the sun, and Earth also rotates by itself. Think about it, everyone: Who’s pushing them? Who has given them the force? You cannot understand it with an ordinary person’s mentality, as it is just this rotating mechanism. The same is also true with our Falun, for it just rotates. (well, I guess he did attend highschool, but not much past it)

    If you are a true practitioner, our Falun will safeguard you. I am rooted in the universe. If anyone can harm you, he or she would be able to harm me. Put simply, that person would be able to harm this universe. Casually disclosing so many heavenly secrets to everyday people is not allowed. But there is one point to be made. Now, times have changed. My fashen are so numerous that they are uncountable. Besides these practitioners, no matter how many more people there are, I am still able to take care of them.

    In our Milky Way, there are over one hundred such paradises. Our Falun Dafa also has a Falun Paradise.


    On one occasion I had my mind connected with four or five great enlightened people and great Taos from extremely high levels. Speaking of high levels, their levels were so high that everyday people would find it simply inconceivable. They wanted to know what was on my mind. It is absolutely impossible for other people to read my mind, and other people’s supernormal abilities cannot reach me at all. Nobody is able to understand me or know what is on my mind.

    After seeing me, some people will hold my hand and not let it go. When others see these people shaking my hand, they will also shake my hand. I know what is on their mind. Some people are very happy to shake hands with Teacher. Some people want to get some messages and will not release my hand. We have told you that true cultivation practice is your own business. We are not here for healing and fitness, or to give you some messages and heal your illnesses; neither are we concerned with those things. Your illnesses will be cured directly by me. Those who practice at exercise sites will have my fashen to cure their illnesses. Those who study Dafa by reading the book on their own will also have my fashen to cure their illnesses. Do you think that you will increase gong by touching my hand? Isn’t that a joke?
    .....

    And numerous others. I've heard mor eoutragous things in the lecture by one of his "masters" during a lecture in a University.

    This guy essentially proclaim himself as God, and the only one, teaches other not believe anything scientific, not worrying about illness etc, only if they worship him. If you are now interested in being saved by him, you can start reading his book here:
    http://www.falundafa.org/book/eng/zflus.html
    Of course you won't know in fullness what he was saying to uneducated rural Chinese people in Chinese--that's why I prefer you can read Chinese.


    He was a postal worker, then a hooligan, then a charlatan, then a charlatan used by some people outside China with political purpose.

    There are no short of charlatan throughout China's long history. This guy probablly is among the biggest. Were it not be western backs like CIA though, he won't amount to anything either. His organization did many illegal things in China, which in part allow himself to live a rich life in US, enjoying superior medical checkup at least twice a year :D :D.

    The saga about Falun Gong is a sad story, but the way it's being used by some Americans is sadder. Everytime there is someone set himself on fire for Falun gong, I am reminded some similar cult in the US....
     
    #11 michecon, Sep 8, 2002
    Last edited: Sep 8, 2002
  12. rockHEAD

    rockHEAD Member

    Joined:
    Mar 22, 1999
    Messages:
    10,337
    Likes Received:
    123
  13. HayesStreet

    HayesStreet Member

    Joined:
    Oct 1, 1999
    Messages:
    8,507
    Likes Received:
    181
    Nothing in your post indicates anything close to justifying the violent crackdown on Falun Gong. More background...

    "Not much is known about Li Hongzhi, 48, the man who created Falun Gong in 1992. He worked as a grain clerk in northeast China's Liaoning province. He played trumpet in a troupe run by the forestry police in neighboring Jilin. And then he wrote a very odd book that affected millions.

    Li's rambling dissertation, Zhuan Falun, has only added to accusations that Falun Gong is a cult. Li writes he can personally heal disease and that his followers can stop speeding cars using the powers of his teachings. He writes that the Falun Gong emblem exists in the bellies of practitioners, who can see through the celestial eyes in their foreheads. Li believes "humankind is degenerating and demons are everywhere"—extraterrestrials are everywhere, too—and that Africa boasts a 2-billion-year-old nuclear reactor. He also says he can fly.

    Wacky, perhaps. But is Falun Gong a cult? Not necessarily, if classic characteristics of cults are taken into account. A reckoning:

    Typical Cult Techniques Falun Gong's Record
    • Exerts tremendous pressure on people to join NO
    • Fosters an us-versus-them approach to life YES
    • Believers remove themselves from society NO
    • Uses jargon that outsiders don't understand YES
    • Believers required to donate large sums of money NO
    • Led by a charismatic master YES

    If someone were to call you a big Capital Economy Liberalization Element, how would you react? If you were in China, you'd be wise to duck. That's the label being applied to He Qinglian, a Shenzhen-based journalist whose books and articles on economics—of all subjects—are bestsellers throughout China. After publishing A Comprehensive Analysis of China's Current Social Structural Evolution in March, He was slammed for propagating dangerous ideas. Last month she was demoted from her position at the Shenzhen Legal Daily and had her salary cut. Editors around the country were warned not to publish her work. "As an intellectual in China," He says, "a mishap could come"—she snaps her fingers—"just like this."

    Beijing is once again cracking its whip on intellectuals and artists, and large numbers are feeling the lash. Among those targeted are four prominent members of the prestigious Chinese Academy of Social Sciences. Li Shenzhi, a political scientist who advised former Chinese Premier Zhou Enlai, was blacklisted from publishing for posting a critical article on the Internet last December. Fan Gang and Mao Yushi, two high-profile economists, were upbraided for publicly advocating privatization and banned from teaching. Liu Junning, a political scientist and popular guest lecturer at various Beijing universities, lost his post at the social sciences academy, purportedly for granting interviews to foreign journalists. Liu is better known for advocating more democracy in China. "We can only guess," Liu replies when asked why he was sacked. "One reason is because there has been a real rise in liberal ideas in recent years."

    Unlike China's political pogroms of the past, this crackdown is muted. Officially, there is no campaign. No new slogans have been launched, though President Jiang Zemin regularly rails against society's "poisonous weeds," which can refer to any high-profile display of free expression, from articles denouncing corruption to racy novels and films. The crackdown follows a period of relative lenience, particularly for academics critiquing China's economy and society. And that is the Chinese pattern. "Repression in China flows in and out like the tide," says Liu Qing, who spent 10 years in Chinese jails as a political prisoner and now runs the New York City-based group Human Rights in China. "It's always present. It's just that sometimes it's enforced gently and sometimes severely."

    The tides always have political undercurrents, and there are several in today's China. Most obvious is the leadership's jitters in advance of the 16th Communist Party congress to be held 25 months from now, at which Jiang's successor will probably be named. "Those who wish to remain in power," says Liu, now a visiting scholar at Harvard's Fairbank Center for East Asian Research, "want to show they're not breaking ranks from the orthodox ideology and, in fact, are protecting it."

    Another impetus for a crackdown is a feeling that free expression is getting out of control in China. For the past year, Beijing has tried—with limited success—to smother the Falun Gong spiritual movement. Just two weeks ago Beijing police had to drag 100 sect members from Tiananmen Square to avoid disrupting the official reception for Russian President Vladimir Putin. Protests by laborers have mushroomed across the country. In the past two weeks alone, 1,000 workers surrounded a People's Liberation Army uniform factory in Chengdu to protest a possible closure of the plant, and 10,000 teachers threatened to take trains to Beijing to decry low wages. "If you're a top official sitting in Beijing," says Ding Xueliang, a social scientist at Hong Kong University of Science and Technology, "and you get news that 10,000 workers are blocking a road, you consider it a sign of big social trouble. You call up all the government monitoring organs and ask them to send you lists of troublemakers."

    Included on that list these days are journalists who expose dirty deals and official malfeasance. Not long ago they were allies of Jiang's government, which publicly vowed to root out official corruption. No longer. "They simply raked up too much muck," says Sophia Woodman, Hong Kong-based research director of Human Rights in China. "The government can't begin to clean it all up." Creative artists are feeling the heat, including best-selling novelist Zhou Weihui, whose racy work has been denounced as "decadent," and urban angst-chronicler Wang Shuo. Both have had their books proscribed, although Wang takes that as a point of pride. "If your work hasn't been banned," he shrugs, "maybe it's not good enough." Novelists aren't much harmed by government bans, thanks to China's massive underground publishing industry, which can churn out whatever the public wants. Some intellectuals can ride out a crackdown too, especially if they are associated with privately funded think tanks. "There are a handful of independent Chinese entrepreneurs who like to support scholars who have fresh ideas," reports Andrew Nathan, professor of political science at New York's Columbia University.

    But Beijing's new cycle of repression is just beginning—and it's likely to get worse before it gets better. Huang Qi is now in jail in Chengdu on charges of subversion. His crime: running a website that featured topics not covered by the state-controlled media. At 5 p.m. on June 3, the day before the 11th anniversary of the Tiananmen massacre, police arrived at his office asking him to accompany them to the station house for interrogation. Huang demanded a written summons and bought himself about half an hour of freedom. He posted updates on his situation, reporting that police were searching his premises. In real-time, he described them confiscating notebooks, photos and computers. Then the arresting officers arrived, and Huang typed his final message: "Thanks to everybody devoted to democracy in China. They are here now. So long." TimeAsia.com
     
  14. pasox2

    pasox2 Member
    Supporting Member

    Joined:
    Dec 31, 2001
    Messages:
    4,251
    Likes Received:
    47
    Falun Gong is a dangerous and evil cult and should be eliminated from the face of the earth. Li is no more or less a religious leader than the Rev. Moon.

    Do a google search. You'll hit their site. I'd never link it.
     
  15. glynch

    glynch Member

    Joined:
    Dec 1, 2000
    Messages:
    18,100
    Likes Received:
    3,609
    Hayes, thanks for starting a very interesting thred.

    What to do with cults that call themselves religious is an interesting problem.

    I know Germany has outlawed Scientology under their laws. In the US it is now treated as a religion.

    I don't know the answer.

    Another interesting question is what is it about Chinese society (intense poverty or lack of freedom?) that causes such a cult to spread so rapidly.

    It also makes me think of how Christianity was veiwed when it started. Of course many Christian ministers have made a bundle off of religious scams. It can be difficult at times to separate a cult from a new religion.
     
  16. Mrs. JB

    Mrs. JB Member

    Joined:
    Sep 15, 2001
    Messages:
    2,086
    Likes Received:
    0
    What exactly is the difference between a religion and a cult anyway? Seems to me that it's all a matter of your perspective.
     
  17. Panda

    Panda Member

    Joined:
    Jun 5, 2002
    Messages:
    4,130
    Likes Received:
    1


    You are quite disappointing to me if you can't see in the script michecon listed that Falun Gong is an evil cult under the disguise of the religion, when their leader Li Hong Zhi evelate himself to a divine status equal to the universe and delcared that he can cure every illness directly.

    This guy is a major crook.

    I've talked about Falun Gong a while ago on this board, since this thread is interested in it. I'll quote what I've posted here before as it's basically my overall views on the true colors of Falun Gong and why the American government is behind it.

     
  18. michecon

    michecon Member

    Joined:
    May 19, 2002
    Messages:
    4,983
    Likes Received:
    9
    hahah, you amused me more. You started a thread asking what is Falun Gong, while knowing little about it. After I gave you some details about what they were about, you ducked the discussion about falun gong and posted a lengthy article about political opressions, essentially asking others to defend again. Frankly, I won't waste my time again. I won't take your claim of wanting to save lives seriously either if you want to justify for Falun Gong.
     
    #18 michecon, Sep 8, 2002
    Last edited: Sep 8, 2002
  19. michecon

    michecon Member

    Joined:
    May 19, 2002
    Messages:
    4,983
    Likes Received:
    9
    There is a valid point here, although I don't totally agree. But I do think religion validates themself through history and adapt enough to the society to survive.
     
  20. Panda

    Panda Member

    Joined:
    Jun 5, 2002
    Messages:
    4,130
    Likes Received:
    1
    Liars are liars, no matter how good they are they can't make their lies round, as liars rely on exaggeration and distortion to make lies.

    First of all, this Falun Gong is a sneaky organization. It tries make itself more appealing by saying it's a traditional practice, and then it proceeds to say it's introduced to the public in "1992" by LiHongZhi. Since I don't think things since 1992 can be considered traditional, here is a question, why does it fail in introduce its origin? ya know, that how long it's dated back in Chinese history and originated by whom? The fact is, it has no origin before 1992, it's a brainchild of Li to perpetrate his mind controlling purpose through bodily practice.

    Falun Gong is a form of new Qigong practice made up by LiHongZhi. Qigong refers to numerous mental process, or meditation means in China. Some of them are old with hundred years of history, some of them are new as people keep invented new methods over the old ones. Falun Gong is a new 10-year-old "Qigong" practice combined with so called "moral teachings" invented by Li. That's why it's not traditional

    Let me ask this question, if one made some new music by changing the style and lyrics of traditional folklores, can he pass it off as "traditional" folklores?

    Inconsistency abounds in lies.

    Furthermore, if that "Chinese government survey" is a reliable source, or may I say, not made up by the Falun Gong members, then why DIDN"T they give reference to that survey to back up their claim of 70-100 million Chinese members?

    In fact, even that estimation was done by a Chinese government survey, it's not so hard to see the ridiculousness of such survey. To put things in perspective, it's simply not impossible that there's one Falun Gong member among every 13 Chinese! Only in their wildest dreams!

    I guess the trick here is that there's might be such a survey, but it's done not by a credible government agency, but some informal survey conducted by some sina research persons, who might worked in government so that such survey can be linked indirectly and deceivingly to the government. So that Falun Gong can, again, through twisting and distorting situation, borrow Chinese government's authority to perpetuate its populairty in China and gain more support.

    Liars are just liars, but these Falun Gong members are no ordinary liars, and they present different faces to different people from different backgrounds. I suspect that LiHongZhi tells his "I'm a buddha reincarnation" BS to Chinese people as Chinese are into buddhism, and then tries to portray Falun Gong as only a meditation process for personal health with some spiritual slogan such as "Truthful, Merciful, Forbearing" in front of foreiners, as they know Buddhism doesn't appeal well to the westerners. Talk about a multifaceted ameba.

    "Truthful, Merciful, Forbearing", this kind of slogans reminds me of the evil cult called "Religion of Truth" that engineered the poisonous gas leakage incident in subway some years ago in Japan.

    It's really sad, that something like Falun Gong can be used as a crutch in political affairs.
     

Share This Page