Voting is based on front court, back court, overall offence, inside offence, outside shooting, overall defence, post defence, perimeter defence, bench, chemistry...and then individual match-ups (starting line up only) If you score a point for each, that is 15 points total, there should be a winner decided. rednation pg: Isiah Thomas sg: Pete Maravich sf: John Havlicek pf: Charles Barkley C: Bill Russell Bench G: Dennis Johnson F: James Worthy C: Dave Cowens vs Fadeaway: PG: Gary Payton SG: Reggie Miller SF: Chris Mullin PF: Tim Duncan C: David Robinson Bench: Chris Paul Shawn Marion Shawn Kemp
front court: fadeaway back court: rednation overall offense:rednation inside offense:fadeaway outside shooting:rednation overall defense: fadeaway post defense: fadeaway perimeter defense:rednation bench:rednation chemistry: fadeaway rednation pg: Isiah Thomas sg: Pete Maravich sf: John Havlicek pf: Charles Barkley C: Bill Russell vs Fadeaway: PG: Gary Payton SG: Reggie Miller SF: Chris Mullin PF: Tim Duncan C: David Robinson rednation: 8 fadeaway: 7
Front Court: RedNation Back Court: Fadeaway Overall Offense: RedNation Inside Offense: Fadeaway Outside Shooting: tie Overall Defense: tie Post Defense: Fadeaway Perimeter Defense: Fadeaway Bench: RedNation Chemistry: tie Individual Matchups rednation pg: Isiah Thomas sg: Pete Maravich sf: John Havlicek pf: Charles Barkley C: Bill Russell vs Fadeaway: PG: Gary Payton SG: Reggie Miller SF: Chris Mullin PF: Tim Duncan C: David Robinson RedNation: 6 Fadeaway: 6 RedNation should put Hondo on SG and Worthy on SF. RedNation does have slighty better overall team and that's why he would win.
[Front Court] RedNation. Duncan and Robinson are very strong, but when you add Havlicek and depth, Team RedNation takes it. [Back Court] fadeaway. Like that trio more than Team RedNation's. With Front and Back Court votes, Havlicek in the front court or back court switches the vote. [Overall Offense] RedNation. I think it'd be a little bit more fluid. [Inside Offense] fadeaway. [Outside Shooting] fadeaway. [Overall Defense] fadeaway. Two starters on Team RedNation are notriously bad defenders. [Post Defense] fadeaway. Russell can't match the defense of Duncan and Robinson. [Perimeter Defense] RedNation. Havlicek was epic and Thomas better than average. Again, a switch of Havlicek would switch the vote. [Bench] RedNation. Paul is great, but Cowens and Worthy were better than Kemp and Marion. [Chemistry] RedNation. Too tough, but when in doubt I'm going with the team whose best player plays to make his teammates better. [Point Guard] RedNation. Very close. [Shooting Guard] fadeaway. [Small Forward] RedNation. [Power Forward] fadeaway. RedNation. [WINNER] RedNation. (8-7)
rednation pg: Isiah Thomas sg: Pete Maravich sf: John Havlicek pf: Charles Barkley C: Bill Russell Bench G: Dennis Johnson F: James Worthy C: Dave Cowens vs Fadeaway: PG: Gary Payton SG: Reggie Miller SF: Chris Mullin PF: Tim Duncan C: David Robinson Bench: Chris Paul Shawn Marion Shawn Kemp Frontcourt- Who has the better FC RedNation - i judge the 3, both front and back court...This was a tough choice... but im going with redN, russel is a defensive beast and barkley is a great rebounder and defender also... hond supplys the offensive punch off the wing... duncan is greatest pf ever, with a nice pairing with drob is great but i dont like mullin in the starting lineup, much rather see marion starting... this was extremely tough but russel > drob , hondo >> mullin , duncan << barkley... one aligator mouth in favor of redN... Backcourt- Who has the better BC RedNation - again mullin kinda screws it over for fadeaway... payton and miller is a nice offense and defense combo... isiah and pete is more blanced players on both sides... but again hondo >> mullin... thus advantage... Bench- WHo has the better bench Fadeaway - all three of fade's bench players play both sides of the ball with more athleticism.. while redN has more of specific role players... Offense- Which team has the better overall team offense. Which teams offense would run smoother and be more effective. fadeaway - mullin can shoot, miller is lights out, duncan with drob are killin the post offensivily...redN has a nice bc pairing offensivly with of pete/isiah/hondo and while, yes barkley and russell can score, their strength is defense... edge to fadeaway's overall offensive balance... Defense- Which team plays better defense? This includes team defense as well as individual defense Tie - this is tough for me to decide... both have good interior defenders and both teams have good outside defenders, whether starting or off the bench... its even to me... or atleast too close for me to choose Chemistry- which team would have better chemistry and work together better. For example, a team full of scorers who like to keep the ball in their hands wouldn't work very well. Tie - no chemistry killers or problems forseen... fadeaway in 7... i know i picked RedNation in alot of the categories but thats because of mullin starting... i forsee marion getting more PT and feel like fade's team is overall better built and constructed...
I dont mind this system either. In general I don't care what system we use as long as the judging criteria is stated before the draft and the judges stick too it.
front court: fadeaway back court: Rednation overall offense:fadeaway inside offense:fadeaway outside shooting:fadeaway overall defense: Rednation post defense: Rednation perimeter defense:fadeaway bench:rednation chemistry: fadeaway rednation pg: Isiah Thomas sg: Pete Maravich sf: John Havlicek...tie pf: Charles Barkley C: Bill Russell vs Fadeaway: PG: Gary Payton SG: Reggie Miller SF: Chris Mullin....tie PF: Tim Duncan C: David Robinson rednation: fadeaway: 9-7
If I had to split hairs Hondo is the better player, but Mullin is the better shooter and scorer. Sorry Mate... I have 1 bar of Internet coverage at moment, will try and vote on all.
FC:Fadeaway BC: Red Offense: Fadeaway Inside: Fadeaway Outside: Fadeaway Defense: Fadeaway Post:Fadeaway Perimeter: Red Bench: Red Chemistry: Red 4-6 Fadeaway Matchup rednation pg: Isiah Thomas sg: Pete Maravich sf: John Havlicek pf: Charles Barkley C: Bill Russell vs Fadeaway: PG: Gary Payton SG: Reggie Miller SF: Chris Mullin PF: Tim Duncan C: David Robinson 3-2 Red Overall 7-8 winner Fadeaway
