QUESTION: TEXAN FAN - Would you Take McNabb

I'd actually consider it. He can throw it. I think he's a better pass than Vick.

 

You didn't start a Vince Young thread...fail

 

I would definitely bring in McNabb. He knows the system and would be worth taking a chance on. As long as the price is right.

 

Easily.

I havent really watched McNabb to closely recently but I can only assume he's more durable than Schuab and plays alot smarter than Rosenfels.

Hes in the early 30's so he should be good for another 3-4 pretty good years.

 

If this were Schaub's third straight year of being hurt and starting off slow, I'd say yeah. But will McNabb want to come here? I imagine there must be a situation where a team is closer to the Super Bowl that could use him.

I would like to see the Texans take a QB in this draft and develope him.

 

I voted No. Let's trade for his back up Kevin Kolb

 

McNabb probably wants to be part of a franchise where the expectations are lower. Here he will have a young back similar to westbrook in Slaton, Andre Johnson, Owen Daniels, Kevin Walter and a welcoming fan base.

I would go for him

 

Yes, is this even a question? McNabb hasn't had an elite receiver to throw to since Owens. And Owens was a nutjob. McNabb to Johnson? That's a winning formula right there.

 

I literally can't get over the fact that he threw up doing the Super Bowl.

 

McNabb will go to a talented team who needs a QB to be a contender. The Texans have no chance at him other than to break the bank and offer more money than anyone else. Houston is probably the last team on his list.

We all know that Kubiak and Schaub will live or die as Texans next season. If they somehow decide to go another direction, I don't think a short-term player like McNabb is the answer.

 

Cheap. Just how I like my women.

 

You win

 

We have 10holes on defense and we need to use our picks on that not on a QB with maybe 4 good years left.

 

so which one of these is a hole - demeco or mario?

 

I think he meant everybody but Petey Faggins.

 

It ain't the QB. It's the offensive line.

 

No, it's the running game. Nope--it's the LADDERS!

 

The O line isn't great, but they aren't the reason we lead the league in QB turnovers.