1. Welcome! Please take a few seconds to create your free account to post threads, make some friends, remove a few ads while surfing and much more. ClutchFans has been bringing fans together to talk Houston Sports since 1996. Join us!

Operation Iraqi Freedom...Of The Press?

Discussion in 'BBS Hangout: Debate & Discussion' started by MacBeth, May 5, 2004.

  1. MacBeth

    MacBeth Member

    Joined:
    Aug 19, 2002
    Messages:
    7,761
    Likes Received:
    2
    Citing constant and "suffocating" US censorship, many of the staff of the US-funded newspaper Al Sabah have resigned. I'm sure we must have a good reason...

    Staffers quit at U.S.-backed Iraq paper

    'Suffocated' journalists prepare to start their own publicationBy Daniel Williams

    Updated: 4:44 a.m. ET May 05, 2004BAGHDAD, May 4 - Many of the editors and reporters at al-Sabah newspaper, a U.S.-funded publication that occupation officials have called a model for journalism in the Middle East, walked out this week and said Tuesday that they would launch their own paper. American overseers had threatened their future editorial independence, they alleged.


    "We thought that the Americans were here to create a free media," Ismael Zayer, who had been editor-in-chief, said in an interview. "Instead, we were being suffocated."

    Zayer said he could not accept the plan by the American administrator of Iraq, L. Paul Bremer, to keep the Arabic-language paper within the Iraqi Media Network, a body that occupation officials created to develop a public broadcasting service. Zayer contended that the newspaper would be subject to interference by a future Iraqi government.

    David Sedgley, program director for the Iraqi Media Network, dismissed Zayer's opinions as the "complaints of a disgruntled employee." He said the future network board of governors would provide only a guiding hand to the newspaper, television and radio operations.

    Latest setback
    The Coalition Provisional Authority that has ruled Iraq for the past year says the media network is being modeled on the British Broadcasting Corp. Simon Haselock, head of media development and regulation for the authority, said in an interview Tuesday that he had designed a corporate structure for the organization at the authority's behest.


    The exodus from al-Sabah is the latest setback in U.S. efforts to shepherd Iraq into a new media era. The undertaking has faced allegations of wasted funding and uninspired programming. Many Iraqis view the media outlets created by the program as mouthpieces of the occupation, not independent voices.

    The resignations come as many Iraqis want to break free of U.S. control in advance of the scheduled June 30 transfer of sovereignty to a new government. Iraqi political and religious leaders have chafed at U.S. plans to select an interim government to lead the country to elections. The proposals are being reworked by U.N. envoy Lakhdar Brahimi.

    The journalists said Tuesday that leaving a publication controlled by the occupation authority would enhance their credibility. "We want our sovereignty now," said Shaker Anbari, the former culture section editor.

    The planned new newspaper is to begin publication later this week under the name al-Sabah Jdeed. Sabah means morning and jdeed means new.

    Staff members said they were putting up initial funds themselves and would seek to keep it going with commercial revenue and possibly contributions.

    The publication they left is one of the largest-circulation dailies among the scores of papers that have opened in Iraq since the fall of former president Saddam Hussein a year ago.

    Dangerous occupation
    Zayer was one of several exiled journalists hired to run the publication. He fled Iraq in 1980 for Germany after repeated jailings for opposition political activities and worked for many years as a correspondent for the London-based al-Hayat newspaper.

    He said censorship at al-Sabah was rare, although U.S. overseers recently tried to block publication of an advertisement from a new political group that complained of the "grief of occupation."

    Zayer and other former staff members said that working for a newspaper under U.S. control had become a dangerous occupation. In March, three employees of the newspaper died in an ambush in northern Iraq; Zayer himself has been the target of two assassination attempts, including an attack on his offices with rocket-propelled grenade and rifle fire.

    Al-Sabah Jdeed is operating from a house once used as a distribution office by al-Sabah. On Tuesday morning, a few dozen staffers crowded into the building to set up offices, plug in computers and prepare for this week's inaugural edition.

    Development of the Iraqi Media Network is being overseen by the Florida-based Harris Corp., which last January won a $96 million contract to carry out the job. Sedgley is an executive at Harris.

    The telecommunications equipment maker subcontracted the task of training and overseeing al-Sabah to a Kuwaiti publisher.

    For the moment, a former Zayer deputy, Maher Faisal, is in charge of putting out the original al-Sabah. It was not clear how many of the original staff had fled. Faisal said that he and "five or six hard workers" put out Tuesday's edition and that he was working to recruit replacement staff. Faisal once worked for al-Jumhuriya, one of Hussein's official newspapers.

    "We don't need the independence Zayer talks about," he said. "We only have to publish credible information. These exiles have nothing to teach Iraqis. We can work without them."

    © 2004 The Washington Post Company
     
  2. FranchiseBlade

    Supporting Member

    Joined:
    Jan 14, 2002
    Messages:
    51,807
    Likes Received:
    20,465
    I think we have a problem in that some people see 'Freedom' and 'Pro-American' as synonymous.
     
  3. Woofer

    Woofer Member

    Joined:
    Oct 10, 2000
    Messages:
    3,995
    Likes Received:
    1
    Older article but on topic. Weird how the American media conspiracy to emphasize the bad spread to Iraq. ;)

    http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/articles/A45979-2004Apr27.html

    Welcome to Baghdad, Texas

    By Jefferson Morley
    washingtonpost.com Staff Writer
    Tuesday, April 27, 2004; 10:20 AM


    Iraq has a free press for the first time in decades, thanks to the U.S. overthrow of Saddam Hussein last year. But those in the White House and the media who expected displays of gratitude and support for U.S. policies from the Iraqi public will be disappointed by what the Iraqi press corps and Baghdad dailies have been saying in the past week.



    A survey of the Baghdad press, as translated by the Iraqi Press Monitor and the World News Connection (subscription required) , shows most Iraqi commentators demand the end of the U.S. occupation, with one calling President Bush's policies "surreal."

    Similar to the reputation of their American counterparts, Iraqi editors and reporters are often viewed as "liberal," if that term implies skepticism of governmental institutions, criticism of authority and faith in the collective good over profit or power. This is not always an easy agenda to promote in a city whose five million people have experienced tyranny, liberation, occupation and a spectacular crime wave, not necessarily in that order.

    From the secular communists on the left to the Shiite clerics on the right, Iraqis across the political spectrum want the U.S. occupation to end as soon as possible. Even al-Mutamar, a Baghdad daily sponsored by the Iraqi National Congress (INC)-- a group long backed by the Pentagon that receives money from the U.S. government --takes care to put an anti-U.S. occupation spin on its editorial positions and the independent daily al-Mashriq reported last week that INC chief Ahmed Chalabi is positioning himself closer to Moqtada Sadr, a radical Shiite cleric fighting the occupation. (The Post reported on Saturday that administration officials are fed up with Chalabi, a member of the governing council, and may cut off his $340,000 a month stipend.)
    To be sure, Baghdad's dailies also run the kind of news stories for which the occupation authority and many Americans would be glad to take credit.

    "Plastic surgery for Saddam's victims," blared one headline in Azzaman. The story reported that a Baghdad hospital is offering remedial plastic surgery on Sundays and Tuesdays to former army deserters who had their ears amputated by Hussein's regime.

    But the style of the Iraqi press is more political than anecdotal. For most Iraqi commentators, the issue isn't Saddam Hussein's cruel tyranny or his non-existent weapons of mass destruction or George Bush's resolve. The issue is the country's profound lack of security. Reading the Baghdad dailies brings home the reality of the city's ongoing crime wave. In the minds of many residents, the looting that began after Hussein's fall last April hasn't really stopped. Indeed, the breakdown in order is likened by some to the free enterprise policies pushed by U.S. authorities.

    A cartoon in the al-Mada daily last week showed a smiling Westernized official holding a document titled "Privatizing the public sector." A masked looter is passing by him, saying "Don't bother. We privatized before you."


    .
    .
    .
     
  4. nyquil82

    nyquil82 Member

    Joined:
    Oct 30, 2002
    Messages:
    5,174
    Likes Received:
    3
    duh, only we are civilized enough to have freedom. give any of those kids over there freedom and they'll use it all up before they realize they have none left! keep them poor and ignorant, thats what they're used to anyway, right?
     

Share This Page