[movie] Lady In The Water

I think its going to fall short at the box office,

People are getting tired of his schtick.

 

Probably more like Floating Turd In The Water.

 

after watching the crap that was the village i'd rather someone just tell me what "the twist" in this one is.

as stupid as it probably will be i'm still curious, i just don't have a desire to sit through this movie.

 

Apparently people are quite confused with the story, and not in a good way. That combined with the terrible rating makes me curious; I've like all his movies thus far though.

But it looks like Disney was right in passing on his script.

 

Some guy at work told me a sports writer wrote this story and M Knight added to, but from what I hear you can only polish a turd so much..

 

Maybe this is the poop thread we've all been missing...

 

Everything M Night touches is gold. I'm definitely seeing this.

 

I will see it
He is a good director . . his writing . . not so much
He still coasting on the fumes of 6th Sense and Unbreakable

Each of his movies is still worse than the one before it
hopefully this will start a upward trend

6th Sense >>> unbreakable > Signs >The village > ???

Rocket River

 

his movies just keep getting worse and worse

 

For the most part I agree with you in that 6th Sense was the only one that didn't hurt me but I actually put Signs as his worst. The "twist" in the Village was stupid and obvious from very early on, but at least there was a love story in the middle that had little to do with the twist. Usually his scripts spend 1-2 hours telling you there is a twist and then - bam - there is a twist and we are supposed to say "wow!" or something. Just thinking about Signs makes me want to bleed from my eyes.

 

M. Night looks like the black Michael Jackson.

 

i understand
The Village was just tripe from beginning to end though
it was the one film where his attempt of creating atmosphere failed
because i just could not buy into it

I got into Signs . .but over the course of the movie
it got stupider and stupider

Rocket River
[ASIDE: Why did I have to explain to my 8 yr old son . .. why no one in the Superman movie noticed that when Clark came back Superman came back]

 

Unbreakable was his best, IMO.

 

I loved 6th Sense and Unbreakable. Signs was nothing great, but worth watching. I liked the music in the beginning. Haven't seen Village because I heard it's the dumbest movie ever. I heard there isn't even a twist, it's just so predicable, and its a lot worse than Signs. That scared me off. As far as Lady in the Water, it looks weird, but I'll wait and see what the critics have to say. I'll watch it because Night said there's a big twist at the end. I love those types of movies.

 

we have huge debates here everytime a night movie comes out.

i love his stuff. my wife and i will definitely pay to see this one.

 

I actually enjoyed The Village. The scenery and atmosphere of the movie was great. It was better than Signs.

 

I actually enjoyed The Village. The scenery and atmosphere of the movie was great. It was better than Signs.

Then I'll watch it next time it comes on TV.

 

I loved Signs

 

I really enjoyed Signs UNTIL the ending. The atmosphere was great and he did an good job with the alien characters until he decided to show them. It just ruined the entire movie for me.