Welcome! Please take a few seconds to create your free account to post threads, make some friends, remove a few ads while surfing and much more. ClutchFans has been bringing fans together to talk Houston Sports since 1996. Join us!

If I ever get caught exposing myself...

Discussion in 'BBS Hangout' started by Yonkers, Aug 20, 2008.

Tags:

Page 1 of 2

Yonkers Member

Joined:

Jun 19, 2002

Messages:

8,433

Likes Received:

480

I will definitely not be using this defense

http://www.chron.com/disp/story.mpl/front/5954517.html

A promise and a prediction. I will do my best not to insert bad puns into this column.

I will fail.

Houston's 14th Court of Appeals on Tuesday upheld the conviction of a local doctor for indecent exposure.

The court rejected the argument by high-profile attorney Dick DeGuerin and his associate Neal Davis that the doctor could not have exposed himself to an undercover cop because that which is alleged to have been exposed is too small to have been seen.

I'm not naming the doctor because his two innocent children don't deserve the playground abuse that would come both from their father's crime and the defense that he and his attorneys decided to pursue.

A walk in the woods
The story begins on a Monday afternoon nearly two years ago with two plainclothes vice officers in separate cars looking for perverts in Memorial Park.

One of the officers, Daniel Leal, testified that he noticed that a car was following him and pulled into a parking lot. He said the suspect pulled up next to him and, making eye contact, began fondling himself.

Leal said the man, wearing a dress shirt, tie and dress pants, got out of his car and approached him.

He said the man asked him if he wanted to come sit in his car, but Leal said he'd rather go over to a wooded area.

Leal said that, in the woods, the man pulled up his T-shirt and massaged his abdomen, then the suspect started undoing his own pants but stopped when two men walked nearby.

Just wanted to talk
At Leal's suggestion, they moved to a spot behind a nearby men's room, where the doctor asked Leal to "Let me see."

Leal says he declined but said, "You let me see."

Leal says the doctor did, whereupon Leal put him under arrest and was joined by his partner.

At trial the doctor gave a considerably different version. He said he went to the park during a 20-minute work break and just wanted to talk to someone.

He said Leal was the first one to make eye contact, they both got out of their cars at the same time and he neither fondled nor exposed himself.

He said he agreed to go into the woods at Leal's suggestion just to continue a conversation in which they talked about "usual stuff" such as marriage and family.

He said Leal lifted his own shirt to show off his stomach muscles and ordered him to do the same.

Even though he was uncomfortable about it, the doctor said he began untucking his shirt, then they heard some people.

He said at Leal's suggestion they moved behind the restroom, which was locked, and he did lift up his shirt, at which time he was arrested.

The jury found the doctor guilty, and the judge gave him six months in jail, but suspended the sentence to two years of community supervision.

The doctor had not used DeGuerin and Davis for the trial but hired them for the appeal.

What might be called the 2.8-inch issue (as measured by a urologist DeGuerin called as an expert witness during a subsequent hearing) did not come up at the trial.

The original attorney testified at the hearing the doctor never told him about his physique. The doctor disagreed, testifying that he mentioned it at their first meeting, but the lawyer said it "would be demeaning to bring up in court" and "this case is about exposure, not about size."

But DeGuerin and Davis argued that it was a key bit of evidence. For one thing, the doctor said he is so embarrassed that he avoids exposure to anyone but his wife.

Secondly, the urologist testified that given the officer's own description of how the doctor allegedly showed off, the illegal part of the alleged display would have been concealed by the doctor's palm, which the urologist measured as being more than half again as large as the subject at hand.

In a 30-page opinion clinically crafted to avoid double-entendres, Justice Wanda McFee Fowler (writing for a unanimous three-judge panel) rejected the defense argument.

She said the trial judge could reasonably have believed the trial lawyer that he was unaware of his client's stature. She rejected DeGuerin's argument that it was the lawyer's duty to ask his client about it.

DeGuerin and Davis made other arguments, but the court rejected those as well.

The bottom line: This is a case that could be described as de minimis, a legal term defined by Black's Law Dictionary as "1. Trifling, minimal. 2. (Of a fact or thing) so insignificant that a court may overlook it in deciding an issue or case."
Click to expand...

#1 Yonkers, Aug 20, 2008

bladeage Member

Joined:

May 3, 2005

Messages:

8,909

Likes Received:

153

Haha how cool is it that the attorney is named Dick?

#2 bladeage, Aug 20, 2008
TMac640 Contributing Member

Joined:

Jan 10, 2005

Messages:

5,484

Likes Received:

2

This case needs Dick Pound on the job. STAT.

#3 TMac640, Aug 20, 2008
Mr. Brightside Member

Joined:

Mar 27, 2005

Messages:

18,964

Likes Received:

2,147

Damn, he got 6 months in jail for this? The sentence seems too long.

#4 Mr. Brightside, Aug 20, 2008
Last edited: Aug 20, 2008
bladeage Member

Joined:

May 3, 2005

Messages:

8,909

Likes Received:

153

Yea that sentence is too long. Looks like the guy got the short end of the stick.

#5 bladeage, Aug 20, 2008
Yonkers Member

Joined:

Jun 19, 2002

Messages:

8,433

Likes Received:

480

Mr. Brightside said:

Damn, he got 6 months in jail for this? The sentence seems to long.
Click to expand...

2+ months per inch. That does seem long... err...

#6 Yonkers, Aug 20, 2008
pmac Member

Joined:

Oct 10, 2007

Messages:

8,406

Likes Received:

3,274

that would be hard to deal with.

#7 pmac, Aug 20, 2008

SwoLy-D Member

Joined:

Jul 20, 2001

Messages:

37,618

Likes Received:

1,456

too small
Click to expand...

Asian?

"Not Black?" and "Not Irish?" would have worked, too, mind you.

#8 SwoLy-D, Aug 20, 2008
JayZ750 Member

Joined:

May 16, 2000

Messages:

25,432

Likes Received:

13,390

I'm am not for anything this doctor did, mind you, but the fact that it's illegal to walk off into some woods, in private (even though yes, you are technically "in public"), and show somebody (of age) your johnson when they ask to see it, seems a little ridiculous.

#9 JayZ750, Aug 20, 2008
Landlord Landry Member

Joined:

Mar 3, 2008

Messages:

6,857

Likes Received:

296

Yonkers said:

2+ months per inch. That does seem long... err...
Click to expand...

dam, guess I'd get a life sentence

#10 Landlord Landry, Aug 20, 2008
JuanValdez Member

Joined:

Feb 14, 1999

Messages:

35,056

Likes Received:

15,230

JayZ750 said:

I'm am not for anything this doctor did, mind you, but the fact that it's illegal to walk off into some woods, in private (even though yes, you are technically "in public"), and show somebody (of age) your johnson when they ask to see it, seems a little ridiculous.
Click to expand...

That's what I was thinking. I'm not sure what is indecent about the case, other than the entrapment.

Is that measurement at rest or at attention, do you suppose?

Doesn't DeGuerin work for Rusty Hardin's law firm.

#11 JuanValdez, Aug 20, 2008
ima_drummer2k Member

Joined:

Oct 18, 2002

Messages:

36,425

Likes Received:

9,373

Mr. Brightside said:

Damn, he got 6 months in jail for this? The sentence seems to long.
Click to expand...

Well, I think that's the shape of things to come.

#12 ima_drummer2k, Aug 20, 2008
Rashmon Member

Joined:

Jun 2, 2000

Messages:

21,233

Likes Received:

18,250

His other lawyer's name was Ben Dover.

#13 Rashmon, Aug 20, 2008

pmac Member

Joined:

Oct 10, 2007

Messages:

8,406

Likes Received:

3,274

JuanValdez said:

Is that measurement at rest or at attention, do you suppose?
Click to expand...

Does it matter? 2.8 inches...once i got enough cigarettes to purchase a shiv i would end it all.

#14 pmac, Aug 20, 2008
Landlord Landry Member

Joined:

Mar 3, 2008

Messages:

6,857

Likes Received:

296

Rashmon said:

His other lawyer's name was Ben Dover.
Click to expand...

I thought it was Malone......

#15 Landlord Landry, Aug 20, 2008
Rashmon Member

Joined:

Jun 2, 2000

Messages:

21,233

Likes Received:

18,250

Yonkers said:

I will definitely not be using this defense

http://www.chron.com/disp/story.mpl/front/5954517.html
Click to expand...

If you feel the need to consider a defense, just how often do you expose yourself?

#16 Rashmon, Aug 20, 2008
Major Malcontent Member

Joined:

Dec 18, 2000

Messages:

3,177

Likes Received:

211

JuanValdez said:

T
Is that measurement at rest or at attention, do you suppose?
Click to expand...

pmac said:

Does it matter? 2.8 inches...once i got enough cigarettes to purchase a shiv i would end it all.
Click to expand...

ummm...actually its possible to have an above average er...member and be less than 2.8 when...er...not in use.

#17 Major Malcontent, Aug 20, 2008
codell Member

Joined:

Aug 26, 2002

Messages:

19,312

Likes Received:

715

To save face, I would have chosen another defense:

#18 codell, Aug 20, 2008

Royals Ego Member

Joined:

Oct 17, 2007

Messages:

4,744

Likes Received:

154

^ shrinkage

#19 Royals Ego, Aug 20, 2008
bladeage Member

Joined:

May 3, 2005

Messages:

8,909

Likes Received:

153

SwoLy-D said:

Asian?

"Not Black?" and "Not Irish?" would have worked, too, mind you.
Click to expand...

Not Mexican would have worked too.

#20 bladeage, Aug 20, 2008

(You must log in or sign up to post here.)

Page 1 of 2

Share This Page