.....when the adults act like children? This is real stupid & a total waste of tax payer dollars. http://www.chron.com/cs/CDA/story.hts/topstory/1322056 Squirt gun puts teacher in hot water Instructor's use of toy draws assault charges By CINDY HORSWELL Copyright 2002 Houston Chronicle To Maria Ripke, the small, red water pistol she has used in class in recent years is a teaching tool. Bryan and Dana Adkins say it was used to assault their son, not teach him. Now, what began as a science lesson at Baytown Junior School has evolved into a legal battle as the teacher faces charges in municipal court. Ripke, who has taught for 10 years in Baytown's Goose Creek school district, pleaded not guilty Thursday to an assault charge. If convicted of the Class C misdemeanor, she could be fined up to $500. "This whole thing is frivolous harassment," said her attorney, Frank Knight III of Baytown. Knight contends that the charge never would have been filed if the boy's parents were not a teacher at the school and a Baytown police officer. "This is just a police officer using his position to say that 'you can't treat my son that way,' " he said. But Bryan Adkins countered that if a police officer had been charged with assault he would be removed from his duties until the case was resolved. Ripke's status remains unchanged. The charge arose from a Feb. 1 incident in Ripke's sixth-grade science class. She said she has used the plastic squirt gun, small enough to fit in the palm of her hand, for several years to demonstrate kinetic energy -- the energy that results from motion. In a complaint filed Feb. 11, Dana Adkins -- who teaches math at the school -- told police that Ripke had surprised her son by shooting him in the chest with the water pistol during class. After the boy objected, Adkins reported, the teacher laughed and squirted water into his face. The parents asked for a teacher conference on Feb. 4. Three days after that meeting, their 11-year-old son was assigned detention for borrowing paper, the report states. According to the report, Ripke gave police her driver's license for identification but refused to be interviewed about the complaint. She was issued a citation alleging Class C assault. Knight, Ripke's attorney, disputes the mother's account of the second shot from the water gun. Ripke said the boy had asked excitedly to be "squirted again," the attorney said. The father said that, in the conference, Ripke described her use of the toy pistol as an "attention-getter," not a teaching tool. He contends that she uses the water pistol as an inappropriate way to keep students' minds from drifting. Adkins said Ripke assured him that his son would never be squirted again. He said he believes, however, that she was retaliating against his son when she gave him detention, his first, for borrowing a sheet of notebook paper. "The detention slip stacked three complaints against him for that one incident," Adkins said. "It said he failed to be prepared, then argued about it and then failed to follow directions." The parents have since had their son transferred to another science class. Adkins, who once taught a drug awareness class at the campus, said school officials are allowing a double standard in Ripke's case. He said that, a week after she squirted Thomas, another pupil received 10 days of detention for bringing a plastic toy hand grenade to school. Since the charge was filed against Ripke, Adkins said, teachers at the campus have been split into two camps -- some supporting his wife and others supporting Ripke. He added that he believes his wife, who has taught in the Goose Creek district for 14 years, is being harassed for having complained. In one instance, he said, one of her paychecks disappeared from her mailbox in the school office. In another, Adkins said, someone put a stack of 50 "how to lose weight" notices in her mailbox. Melissa Sanchez, a theater arts teacher at the school, attended Ripke's arraignment Thursday to show support. "She taught both of my children and they loved her. She's an excellent teacher," Sanchez said. "She uses different stimuli, from chewing gum to bubbles, to interest the kids in science and make it more relevant. My daughter recalls her using the water gun and thought it was great." Wilyne Laughlin, president of the Baytown Education Federation, also attended the arraignment. "It's always sad to see teachers having problems with their profession. But it's rare to see two teachers in a dispute," she said. "It would have been better handled with discussions between the two professionals rather than going to the courts." A pretrial hearing on the case is set for May 16.
Oh, to be back in the good old days when a teacher wouldn't think twice about firing an eraser or a piece of chalk at a student. I guess I could be rich today if I had sued after getting a swat for not having my name on all of my PE equipment.
Do you think that this teacher would have gotten the death penalty if she had paddled this kid for not being prepared for class?
This is in the town I grew up, I got the HECK out of Baytown, it is a small minded town, with small minded people. We called it the armpit of the world. DaDakota PS. I think the teacher with the squirt gun should be commended, anything you can do to help teach is a good thing.
When I was in the 1st grade, I came home and told my Mom how my teacher used to smack us across the knuckles with a ruler if we got our math problems wrong. This was in 1968, in an HISD elementary school. Shortly thereafter, my Mom became active with the School Board, and she remained active for the next 15 years.
I'm not against corporal punishment for behavior, but for missing math problems? How did they think that could possibly be an effective teaching technique?
We worry about our kids 'emotional' development more than they educational/social development and guess what Kids who do well . . .feel good about themselfs kids who are slacker and are allowed to be slackers become slackers. . . .and in time will know they a slacker no matter how many times u lie to them and say HEY YOU'RE A GOOD GUY . . . We tolerate poor and weak behavior but turn around and wanna say He demand excellence POPPYCOCK!!! Rocket River Give this teacher a medal
God only knows. It was not an effective teaching technique. Throughout my life, mathematics has been a weak point. I can't live without a calculator, and I have a rough time balancing my checkbook. Maybe I should sue HISD. Hmmm...
This article is a prime example of what's wrong with kids today. With our sue happy society, teachers & principals are afraid to discipline the students. When I went to school, if you acted up or caused a disturbance, they busted your butt. The coaches & principals used a half inch thick board with holes drilled in it, so it would whistle (no sound was actually heard, except in your head) on it's way to smacking your butt. While, I & my butt didn't like it at the time, I now look back & realize that every time it was used, I never repeated the offense. Our society has gotten so paranoid they'll be brought up on charges of child abuse, that they let the kids get away with almost anything. The result of this attitude is that many kids have no values, discipline or respect for adults, or anyone else for that matter. That's one of the reason's that kids can take a life so easily & not show any remorse. I put the blame for this on two groups, lawyers & parents. I know that many of the laws are in place to protect the children from genuine child abuse, but whatever happened to common sense? Wait, I'm sorry. I forgot, lawyers & common sense are on opposite ends of the spectrum of life. A friend of mine was spanking her daughter in a grocery store, for acting up, when a stranger made the comment that she shouldn't be doing that. Well, needless to say, that lady was told to mind her own business. Using my sister's kids as an example, they're good kids &, thus far, haven't gotten into any trouble, but they have never uttered the words yes, sir, or mam together so much as once & they speak to adults with disrespect & contempt in their voices & mannerisms most of the time. Discipline, respect, & values are taught at home. Maybe it's time for us to slow down in our pursuits of wealth & stuff, & start focusing more on the kids. By the way, I don't mean to imply that every kid is this way, but I would say the vast majority of them are.
Hottoddie, My 3 year old is already saying Yes Sir, and Yes Mam....it is essential if you have kids to be the adult and teach them respect. DD
Thanks for sharing that DaDakota. It's good to hear that some parents are teaching their kids right. That just happens to be one of my pet peeves. If they don't respect others, then how will they ever learn to respect themselves?
Honestly, this sounds like it has NOTHING to do with the kid. I would bet that these two teachers have a history. The mother/teacher, I just bet, suspects the science teacher of doing some of the things mentioned in the article. My father told me that these types of teacher squabbles are fairly common. They don't always result in lawsuits or criminal charges but he said that there are quite a few teachers he knows who act less mature than his students.
One note on respect... I was raised to be polite and nice and to not fight. However, I have noticed that these are not highly prized values in our extremely competitive way of life in America. Every "nice guy" I've ever known complains mightly about how difficult it is to get women to think of you as more than a friend and to get ahead in business because others are less respectful than you and willing to step on you to get ahead. It would seem to me that we are alternately teaching mismatched values. We teach our kids to be respectful but then tell them they have to be tough and fight for what they want. We want them to be polite and kind but intensely competitive as well. It confuses me and I'm an adult. Imagine how confusing it is for a 5-year-old.
Jeff, This is true, but you can still get ahead and be respectful. You don't always need to step on people to advance in the work place. Hard work and recognizing opportunity is more important. DaDakota
Hottoddie: Outstanding post, dude. As a child of 2 teachers, I can tell you firsthand how pathetic it is now with the attitudes of kids compared to when I was going to school (where you would get paddled if you messed up). My dad taught for 30 years and retired 7 years ago. I honestly think that he would have tried to teach a couple of more years, but he got tired of hearing excuses from parents on why their kids could not behave (he was a guidance counselor but taught 1 class for like his last 15 years). It was sad and heart-breaking to watch someone lose their passion like he did. I feel so sorry for teachers...I mean they are underappreciated and underpaid & they have their hands tied in enforcing rules.