http://www.hoopsanalyst.com/0506ew12.htm He puts Roy and Brewer at the top of the list. Though by his "objective rankings" (based on college stats), Redick is second (behind Roy, of course) and Brewer is fourth. Carney isn't included in the list. He's categorized as a SF (probably due to lack of ball-handling skills).
You must be in the I luv Redick camp along with Rockets Dynasty and DaDakota. You guys always leave out any negative stuff about Redick. This guys opinion is the same one espoused by those who don't want to pick Redick with the 8. 4. JJ Redick, Duke: A great shooter and scorer in college, Redick’s NBA future is still a little cloudy. I do believe his shooting ability will keep him in the league for a long time, but I’m not sure how big of a role he’ll have.
I'm not in the Redick camp, actually. I'd prefer Brewer. I said based on stats, Redick came out second, but his overall assessment was Roy and Brewer are the best. Not sure where the confusion came from.
