i know you're being sarcastic, but i'll treat it as truth since it really is. the board had 40k members. there's probably only around 5 people i consider idiots. you're one of them. look at your responses. you have kidd over stockton. i tell you that stockton is the all-time steals and assists leader and a far superior shooter than kidd. and instead of addressing my points directly, you argue a strawman argument about magic and assists.
I stated a point about how I chose Kidd over Stockton and you clowned me..or tried to(doesnt work when the other doesnt give a damn)......Statwise ,you simple b*stard, Stockton wins in a landslide...BUt mfer I picked Kidd because I think he's better... If its 40k members and only 5 are idiots then you aint being real with yourself...If Im an idiot to everybody , then mission accomplished!!!!!....I speak the truth not kiss up
How is Kidd the better all-around player than Stockton? I'm curious. Not hatin' just real talk, homey. I just wanna get a different POV when it comes to GOAT PGs, feel me?
PGs: Isiah Thomas was better than Nash and Kidd. SGs: Ray Allen has had a nice career, but he is MAYBE top 5. I would honestly put Wade ahead of him, but some might say it's too early to say for sure. Also, Iverson would've been top 5 if only he had gotten that elusive ring... SFs: I guess it is wayyy to early to tell, but I think Durant will have a better career than Pippen. PFs: Well obviously Russell should be with the Center's... Also, wasn't Elvin Hayes really a PF? If so, he is top 5. Cs: Not a real issue with this except Hakeem is ahead of Shaq IMO. 1) Wilt 2) Kareem 3) Russell 4) Hakeem 5) Shaq And Howard may be top 10, but it is hard to imagine him jumping ahead of Shaq or Dream when it is all said and done.
and why do you think he's better? thus far, you've been unable to give any reasoning behind your opinion. all you've provided is a strawman argument.
rather than just say i disagree, ill show you my list then we can discuss the differences. PG 1. magic 2. oscar 3. stockton 4. isaiah 5. kidd SG 1. mj 2. kobe 3. west 4. gervin 5a. pistol 5b. clyde can't leave either guy off the list SF 1. bird 2. baylor 3. dr.j 4. pippen 5. lebron tough to cut hondo, english, and rick barry PF 1. duncan 2. malone 3. hayes 4. garnett 5. barkley C 1. kareem 2. wilt 3. russell 4. shaq 5. hakeem
Dwight Howard will never be a top 5 C. Given the guard-oriented era, he should be dominating a lot more than he currently is. His offensive game isn't half of what Shaq/Dream/Wilt/Kareem's were. Who's he knocking out of the top 5? Russell? No chance there.
this list damn near like mine...a few twist here and there.....funny how Im sure everyones list will be close but they b**** about a few names
Kg over Barkley. The same kg who could never take his team out the 1st round until gasol or pierce took him? I think dirk is better than kg.
Cassel was hitting all those big shots. I saw him more of 2nd fiddle rather than a lead dog. Charles carried teams and so did dirk.
What does it take to convince you that Dwight Howard will not be top 5 of all time? I literally gave you all the evidence I could in the other thread. You're just blindly covering your eyes and saying "I can't hear you".
