If this doesn't choke you up...

I always see people say "That's so sad, she was so cute!" like if she was a homely chick it would be ok.

 

I wouldn't care as much to be honest.

 

I guess I'm not Human. American Idol sucks arse.

awww, how shallow

 

So sad...

 

That would have been the case if he can't sing, but we all heard the guy.

 

They also said he wasn't even the best that night and probably wouldn't have moved on otherwise. Again, I don't know as I don't watch AI and have not watched the clip.

 

It's human nature. You're right her looks before the accident shouldn't matter.

Props to the guy for sticking by his fiancé/wife. No one would blame him for leaving.

 

I understand most people are selfish assholes but he's doing what he's supposed to do.

 

Guy sings well. He doesn't need the story. I also thought like Lil Pun, but I watched the clip. No, I didn't choke up.

 

I disagree. If he left, i wouldn't say he's an *******. I'd say I wouldn't wish his situation on anyone. He's 20 something without children.

 

I hate this show, but that clip did choke me up. he has a great voice.

 

How did you think like me when I have no comments about the guy or his story?

 

This. I'm a fan regardless but Tyler is an unexpected surprise. Randy needs to stop imposing his will on every joke and comment, he's trying to force funny and interesting while Tyler is just letting it happen.

The story of the girl was really sad. I don't think I've ever seen someone so disfigured on a show like this, and for someone to suggest that she is just a tool to advance someones career is unspeakably crass...whether it's the case or not.