I have to say it is a very bad proposal. Redd is another T-MAC,with less talent,and same flaws(too much jumpshot,too much ballcontrol etc.) And Yi,at least now,he isn't suit to play with YAO,because his deficient rebound ability. Villanueva?We have Scola and Landry,he is not necessary. After this trade,we will not get better,but worse!
Well... why not trade for villanueva? That guy is pretty good... he's better than Yi right now but can't start because they're committed to Yi. I mean I don't know if he'd be able to start here... but I've always thought he's a better talent than the minutes he gets nowadays.