I was surprised they have nearly identical ops. I think I'd favor Polanco as he's a free agent. Concerned about what the cards would want for Donovan. From what's been reported it seems what we have to trade will be used for pitching. In ranking it seems that Donovan and Polanco are about even in terms of protection. Josh lowe seems to be trending in the wrong direction. I'm curious to see if altuve will continue to split time between left field and second or go to one full time.
Yes. The Astros made an offer that Seattle beat. He would have made a big difference last season. He’s not as much of a fit now that Houston has Correa but adding Polanco would allow them to trade Paredes or salary dump Walker. SS Pena 1B Paredes LF Alvarez 3B Correa 2B Polanco DH Altuve RF Sanchez/TBD C Diaz CF Cole
I think I like Donovan's age better in that role, but something is better than nothing. I get the feeling Polanco will be headed to DHish duties in the not too distant future.
I think he’d be a good fit on a 1 or 2 year deal but I expect him to get 3 years and more than Houston can offer. But on a 2 year deal he could probably stay viable enough to share 2B/LF/DH duties with Alvarez and Altuve.
The baseball media used a seemingly awful person in Fiers to destroy the reputation and forever vilify Jose Altuve, a seemingly good person.
I remember that the Fiers stuff about him being a creepo was coming out and the Kobe died so all the attention went to that, and Fiers got to slither away down to Mexico...
Exactly because you are only getting Donovan for two more years, so weigh in the prospect cost + Donovan to what a 2-3 year deal for Polanco would be and I bet Polanco is the better value, given he fills a power need the Astros have, and while Donovan does have a higher on base percentage, it's mostly due to average. They both are roughly the same walk rate, but you are getting a lot more power from Polanco. I'll take 15-20+ more HRs over 20+ more singles.
Whats even more upsetting is that they got ajizz pierzynskeeee to ask questions about our team. Eff that guy and his continuous onslaught of hatred for this organization.
At 5 mil per year give me Donovan over signing Polanco.. If a trade for Donovan looked like this. Natthews/Ullola Hicks/Mayer for Donovan.
I see no stats from 2025 so assuming he was injured. His 2024 stats looks great though. I wonder what type of injury he had last year? Tmj surgery??
