Lol you literally said you expected them to look more like BTJ than Odunze. BTJ had 87 receptions, 87 receptions, 1200+ yards and 10 TDs his rookie season for reference.
Maye has not done anything in the league. He wishes he had Stroud's resume. two playoff victories, offensive rookie of the year...
Maye will be and already is the better QB. Why do I say this because although both are very talented, it's obvious Maye has a better grasp of the same offense that both are running. This doesn't mean CJ cant become as good as Maye is in this offense. Plus the fact of Maye is in his 2nd season and CJ's in his 3rd. The main difference is Maye doesn't have Nico/Kirk type WR's to throw too. Which QB appears to be ascending and which QB appears to be descending IYO?