For those of you second guessing Garner, who the hell do you want pitching then?!? One pitch, one out.
You bring in Lidge in this situation 100/100 times, unless he's on the DL. Against the top of the Card's order Womack/Walker/Pujols - you can't put anyone else out there in the 9th, especially since your best hitters are coming up in the bottom half.