In this case, I think the rookie is in the more stable situation. That said, I'd say if you're interested in points and steals, Iverson wins. If you're interested in assists and rebounds, Rose wins. Unlike most rookies, Rose will be consistent all year long. I think this is the best class of fantasy rookies ever. Westbrook is a really good play right now. He will be starting the rest of the year with a team that has only Durant. Lopez has been a very solid rookie for me. Oden is only risky because of the injury bug, not because he is a rookie. Mayo is a decent rookie as well.