Take the ferry boat ride over to Staten Island to take in the Staten Island Yankees game. Always fun, and, if a nice day, the boat ride is beautiful - goes right by the Statue of Liberty.
Yelp will show you all the restaurants you should try Atlantic City casinos- a bus ride away from NYC, lots of stuff to do there, from all card games, to golf, to shopping, resort stuff, and shows Hudson River Park where I used to work has lots of fun activities
I wouldn't have been able to do this without Googling. I'm familiar with them, but not a fan. So I wouldn't know most of their names. I'd have known ODB and Method Man, but that's it.
Go to Tom's Restaurant, the one that was used in Seinfeld. Google the museums; those are always pretty good to go to. Honestly, just chilling in central park is always relaxing. Could check out Columbia's campus and that humongous church at 112th and Amsterdam. I would have to think more, but that is a start.
http://www.robertaspizza.com/ http://www.shakeshack.com/ Walk across Brooklyn Bridge or take a boat tour around Manhattan.
Try this place out, I heard this is the burger to end all burgers http://aht.seriouseats.com/archives/2009/03/secrets_of_minetta_taverns_black_label_burger_1.html
Dang Mystery, I don't know any of the guys you just mentioned! The only one I could think of was.... Spoiler Yea you heard right, "Sine your pitty on the runny kine"!... ....... ....... .......
If you do the Brooklyn bridge walk, try to get there earlier. It can get crowded and isn't very pleasant then...other than watching bikers yell at pedestrians. Boat cruise around part of the island is/was nice. The motor boat covers more area, but being on the sail boat was pretty cool. Hit some golf balls off the pier while you are there. Yankees game. crack. sa da tay