I'll only post what one judge said and keep them anonymous. Because if I post both and the other 2 don't post their scores, then you would know the winner.
Championship Off Def Comp Clu Rocketsman! 1 2 2 2 Torque 2 1 2 3 VBG 2 3 2 2 Jamers 3 2 2 3 Iwqbulb 1 3 3 2 Spooner 3 3 3 3 Rednation 2 3 3 3 Rebuilding Yth Off Def Comp AXG 3 2 1 2 Mickey_Angelo 3 2 2 1 Rocketsman!: Wesley, green and Blair give this team a good upside in the youth section, unfortunately, youth wasn't a category in contending. I believe he should've went rebuilding here. I don't know where the consistent scoring comes from here except Parker. Wesley and Terry could go off any day but as mentioned its not consistent. I would've at least put Blair to start and build around him. Giving up LA isn't a popular decision in my eyes. Usually offense and clutch go hand in hand but I couldn't give him a 1 in that section due to the insane clutchness of Terry in the Finals and Parkers a proven closer also. Torque: Love the plan for the future but I mean are you really going to start an unproven center in Thabeet? The blockbuster for Wade was great but who scores other then him, I gave him a 2 for O though because Gallinari can put up big numbers and Wades an animal. Wades a well proven closer, one of the best in the game, therefore he gets a 3 in clutchness. Who defends on this team besides Wade??? How are you going to split time between Haslem, Martin and Patterson? A lot of questions here if that plan for 2012 doesen't go through....... VBG: Basically did nothing to his team, Mayo's young obviously he's going to do bonehead things, not really a fan of letting him go.. The Grizzlies played awesome last year and that was WITHOUT Rudy Gay. Great defensive team, can score when they need to but not known for putting up Golden State like numbers. Who's clutch on this team?.. Randolph had an MVP like year but before that he was pretty horrid in the clutch, I'm not going to put all my faith in him just yet. Rudy gay had like one game winner against Lebron last year. I gave them a 2 in clutch. Jamers: Basically traded for the Celtics lol. Not a bad thing even though I think KG's close to finished, he can still put it up a good 15-10 game though. Love the Ray Allen addition, gives Durant a sharp shooter and helps him limit his 3 point attempts. Every starter can score big numbers except Perkins. Defense would've been 1 if it wasn't for Perkins, Garnett and Thabo off the bench to guard a 2 or 3. Nice team. AXG: Very young team. Has a lot of upside, they can be a force in a few years. Unfortunately no one can defend on this team except Salmons. I really think Cousin's is going to be a superstar. Mickey_Angelo: Also a very young team. I like the idea of sending Beasely for a true center, if Oden finally pans out, it'll make him look like a genius. Rubio's a born facilitator and I feel he can make Williams and Oden much better then they are. A lot of young personalities, new faces, a practical overhaul, idk how that chemistry will be. Could be disastrous. Iwqbulb: I see where he's coming from with "championship experience" argument but age isn't really on his side at allllll. Camby's a great addition, this team is defensively stacked. Who scores beside Ginobli though? Can Duncan score consistently anymore? This team won't put up too much points. Spooner: This team is stacked up the ass, the bench is incredible also. Westbrook is obviously a superstar along with Nowitzki. Martin and Butler are proven scorers. Wallace gives them toughness and defense, can score when he has too. Chandler is a defensive machine under the basket, great at cleaning up on the offensive side too. McDyess, Jefferson, Beabouis, Hayes hell even Fernandez and Bibby are all very productive off the bench. Spooner ran away with this little competition and it isn't really even close. Rednation: Great team, LA can score buckets, only reason I gave him a 2 on off. is because idk if Pierce can keep up his production on the offensive end because of age. Harden looks promising, Rondo obviously one of the better passers in the game. Ibaka gives them a presence under the basket. Roy off the bench is a good idea due to his unrecoverable injury. The rest of the bench is not that strong. However overall this is a great team. Would've really gave Spooner a run for his money if Roy was the player he use to be.
Should I have the 2nd scores determine the winner? Or drag this out until the other 2 judges post their scores?
Setit up. If we do another one I think I might choose the suns. I want to give nash one more run at it to the title. Would be interesting
I'll post my scores later and drag this out until the others post. Or do you guys just want to determine a winner right now with my scores?
2nd batch OFF/DEF/COMP/CLUTCH Spooner: 3/2/3/3 RedNation: 2/2/2/3 lwqbulb: 1/3/2/2 Jamers: 3/2/2/3 RocketsMAN!: 1/1/2/2 torque: 2/1/2/2 VBG: 2/2/3/2 YOU/OFF/DEF/COMP AXG: 3/2/1/1 mickey_angelo: 3/1/3/1 1. Spooner 23 pt 2. Rednation & Jamers 20 pt 1. Mickey 16 pt 2. Axg 15 pt It's a close battle so far.
I'll acknowledge Sacramento's defense was bad, but how did Minnesota get a 3 in defense when they had the worst defense in the NBA last season?!
#3 as "commissioner" I felt I had to take you goals/strategy into consideration so I made a 5th category. Clutch, off., def., comp., strategy Spooner- 3,3,2,3,3 Rednation- 3,2,2,3,3 Vbg- 3,2,2,3,2 Rocketman!- 1,2,2,3,1 Torque- 2,2,2,3,3 Jamers- 3,2,3,3,3 Iwqbulb- 2,2,2,3,3 Youth, off., def., comp., strategy Axg- 3,3,1,2,2 Mickey_angelo- 3,2,2,3,2
