Luck or Newton??

I don't know.

I watch Andrew Luck and I see the physical tools, but you can't really convince me that he'll be a sure-fire NFL Superstar on par with the Mannings and the Rodgerses.

 

I see Cam Newton as a young Donovan McNabb. I guess he's stronger and more athletic but that's not the type of quarterback that has won championships in this league.

Give me Luck.

 

Cam might be having the greatest rookie qb season ever. The odds say luck will be a bust more than a success. Luck might be real good, but you can't pick someone who has proven it vs someone who hasn't.

 

it's easy to look at it now and say newton, seeing as how he is doing a lot better than what most people thought. Now, if Luck and Newton were both in the same draft class, who would you go with? The risk, in my opinion, is much lower with Luck, although the reward would be greater with Newton. This really isn't even a fair question seeing as how Newton is already pro and Luck has yet to take a snap as a pro. Ask this question after they both play a year of pro and that will be a much better question.

 

Who looks cooler at the line of scrimmage? I have to go with newton and his visor over luck's hand gestures. I really liked how Cam stood up for his kicker at the press conference last week saying they win as a team and lose as a team. The kid has a good head on his shoulders. From all the pre draft hoopla, we were led to believe other things.

 

What Newton has going for him is that we pretty much know he isn't a bust. That doesn't have anything to do with Luck mind you, it's just that I think what was holding Cam back in a lot of people's eyes was the risk that he'd be JaMarcus Russell 2.0

Now obviously Luck is the prototypical #1 Overall Pick Quarterback Prospect in the Palmer/Manning/Aikman mold, in terms of having everything you'd want from a franchise QB. But given Newton's superior physical tools and the fact that he's proven that he can play at this level, I'd probably have to go with Cam.

 

No way, Luck has a higher upside than Newton.

 

Luck. Wouldn't think twice about it.

 

Luck before I ever saw Newton play in the NFL but now not so sure now. Newton is showing that he's quite the stud.

Just as easily as Luck could be the next Manning or Rodgers he could also be the next Ryan Leaf. Cam's already displayed he can play in this league and play really well.

 

Would have said Luck before the season but now I'm going with Newton.

Nobody expected Auburn to win a Championship before the season yet he led them to the Championship.

And he has been very good in the NFL.

 

I would take Newton. He is proven and Luck has a 50 percent change of being very average or worse.