Official "Should I" Thread

Any takes on David Nelson?

I picked him up last week mainly because he was 6'5 in an offense that passes a lot and scores points. Has he emerged as the clear number 2 wr behind stevie johnson?

 

I think Chan Gailey has done wonders with Fitzpatrick, he know the offense line isn't going to protect anyone for very long so he's gone hyper-WCO and Fitzpatrick is getting the ball out right away, which means a lot of opportunities for everyone in that offense. So far Brad Smith looks like a bad fit there.

Now, that **** won't flow against teams who can sit in Cover 2s and pick a short passing game apart, but for an ass-backwards Raiders Defense that Al Davis won't allow to play anything but strict man to man, of course it'll make him look like a world beater.

 

I don't think Dexter gains anymore value than he had before as a simple flex player. Thomas Jones is going to be the featured back and Dexter will be reprising his role as a change of pace back.

I hope I'm wrong because I have Dexter on my team. I see Dexter as a Danny Woodhead type and Jones as Green-Ellis

 

so romo looks like he could be out, status is uncertain, but should i be looking to pick up another QB? we play 2 QB's each week my other QB is schaub. who should i look at picking up?

 

I'm in total panic mode on my QB situation... Should I dump Eli Manning for the Sex Cannon?

 

Nicks active!

 

No...I'd hold onto Eli personally. Who's your other QB? If you have none, I'd cut someone else for Rex just to have options each week..

 

I just traded Tate for Mike Williams (TB). Good move?

 

Great move.

 

cam + branch + benjarvus for nicks and wells?
http://imageshack.us/photo/my-images/508/screenshot20110919at936.png/

 

I'll say yes, since you won't need Cam outside your bye week, and Nicks is an upgrade from Branch (though I actually think he is better than Reggie Wayne right now), and I think Wells is in for a huge year and BJGE will still be splitting carries on a team that doesn't run that frequently.

 

I had offered the Tate + A.J. Green for him last week and got rejected, and now he offered me for Tate straight up. :grin:

Of course, he is probably very happy he didn't trade me Maclin, who I tried very hard to get last week since he was coming off such a bad game.

 

LMAO, I just offered Gore + Holmes for Andre Johnson and some idiot actually accepted my trade.

I

 

Not a terrible trade for either side--esp if the other guy needs a RB.

 

Moe's what do you think about Denarius Moore, should I pick him up?

I am not sure I want to pick up a waiver wire guy, especially a rookie wide out, but I am contemplating picking this guy up.

It might be worth it if he can produce 1000 yards going forward. I just can't see him doing that. He came out of nowhere this week, but once teams know who he is, im afraid he isn't going to be nearly as effective.

Got any thoughts?

 

So I'm 2-0 but have lost Charles for the season and have Steven Jackson dinged up while facing the Ravens. Def a no-go there.

I have Tolbert going against KC.

Tate v Saints or Sproles v Texans or play both and sit Santonio Holmes against Raiders (flex)? TIA

 

I'd go Tate and S Holmes. Easy calls imo. Once Arian is back, then you have tougher calls to make.

 

I am tempted to run both Arian and Tate out there on a hunch. On the road against a dynamic offense, have to own the clock.

 

thanks & repped