Official "Should I" Thread

NO is so dependent on turnovers, and defensive TDs, though Sproles helps if ST TDs count.

I definitely cut KC for Washington. Now that I've looked at next weeks matchups, I'd be tempted to take the Browns since they face the Colts. We haven't seen Denver yet, so it is hard to comment on them.

 

HELL NO!

He better throw in a better receiver than Driver if he wants that deal.

 

Based on what Tate and Ward did last week, you'd be a fool to let Arian Foster go. The guy is already a beast, but when you add AJ, Shaub and Daniels to the mix, it is just a devastating offensive team.

 

alright, i dropped KC and have WAS on waiver, imagine it goes through, i'll wait until after tonights game and ask who i should go with after dropping NO. thanks everyone.

 

I'm saying get rid of KC. I'd wait and see on NO but if they continue to disappoint I'd consider dropping them.

 

yea i'll wait on NO, i'll come back to this thread later tonight after the DEN game see if others believe i should drop NO and get DEN or not. total newb to FF, so depending on you guys to help me most of this season :grin:

 

I'm trying to get him to throw in Boldin instead, it'd be my foster and tate for his MJD and boldin.

I still really don't want to do it as my two other WR's are Andre Johnson and Roddy white (PPR league) but the only thing that makes me think about it is the uncertainty of Foster on a week by week bases and Tate is still uunproven.

 

Then Boldin won't play anyway. Boldin was only a good play in maybe 5 games last season, so I wouldn't do it. It will only be a problem if you don't know in advance the status of Foster. Otherwise, Foster/Tate is better than MJD. Of course I hate wasting a roster spot on a handcuff, but once Foster is healthy you can get rid of Tate.

 

If only I had played Hightower or Tate over DeAngelo Williams. I am already the highest scorer in my league with McFadden still to go, but it would have been nice to crack 200 points.

 

Ok, the deal's parameter's have been changed.

He is now offering:

Jamaal Charles
Mike Williams (TB)
Santana Moss

Greg Jennings
DeSean Jackson or Hakeem Nicks

thoughts?

 

in a heartbeat, and i'd trade D Jax personally...UNLESS H Nicks injury keeps him out much. But it's supposedly a bone bruise

 

It has developed to:

hakeem Nicks
DeSean Jackson
Pierre Thomas

for

J. Charles
Mike Williams
Santana Moss

thoughts?

 

I don't believe in Shonn Greene, and I'm a secondary Jets fan (Go Texans). Do that trade. A backfield of Charles and Rice would be awesome. Mike Williams and Jennings is not too shabby.

 

I don't like this deal at all. Hakeem Nicks and Jennings are two of the most consistent wide receivers in the league. Moss and Williams are not. Period. Even Jamaal Charles shows signs that he is going to be an inconsistent back this year.

So, from my point of view, you are getting 3 maybe will have a good game and giving up a definitely will have good games. If you judge receivers by the offense they are in even D-jack is a better play from week to week than what you are getting.

If I were you, I wouldn't make a trade period for any of your wide receivers.

The deal that I would make however if I would try to trade Shonne Green for Ryan Mathews.

Ryan Mathews is at an all-time low right now, and i bet you could do a deal straight up for him. Now I know that Mathews looks like Shonne Green all over, but hear me out. I believe that the worst Ryan Mathews games are going to be a game like he just had wear he doesn't score, but he gets you at least 100 yards + 3 or for receptions a game, and in those weeks where he breaks off a touchdown run of 30 yards or so he is going to give you a 20 to 25 point game.

I don't see Shonne Green doing that.

 

I don't know how it went from the last one to this one. I would continue to negotiate that one. I'd say "forget Santana Moss" to knock it down from his side, and then chop it down to what it was before. Either DJax/Nicks + Jennings

 

Well, looks like the Denver D just got hit with injuries to Champ Bailey and Elvis Dumervil, so that drops their value significantly. I wouldn't react too much to the actual game score itself though -- for whatever reason Denver always has trouble with Oakland...one of those division rivalry things.

Get the Skins D if you can, with Cincy as a backup option.

 

I doubt I go shopping for Ryan Matthews. I had him last year and couldn't have been more frustrated by him. I'm not willing to go another round with him.

However, is that really what Shonne Green's value is at? I just need a consistent #2 RB.

 

so many guys, all bad teams but will see targets

I don't think you can go wrong (right).. I'd choose Decker or Gaffney probably. But D Jones is as good as any on the list. Just gotta hope

 

Henderson.

Now.

Nownownownownownownownownownownownownownownownownownownownow.