The idea of selling high on Tucker becomes more and more appealing to help replenish the talent in the organization.
43% of his ABs this season have come with runners on base. 40% of his HRs have come with ... runners on base.
Tucker's having the worst season of career besides his rookie seasons. In what way would that be selling high?
He's built a name for himself. Some organizations may pay a good price for him. He still has some control too.
After the 3-0 full take...pitcher threw 2 very nice breaking balls down and in, just out of nowhere. Guy could not find a strike until those last 2 pitches.
"Gotta have Dubin up" "Gotta have Arrighetti up" "Let's see what they can do" "It can't be worse." (of course it can be, always)
Off a gold glove season, under control for 2.5 yrs, still a solid player. There’d be a significant market for him.
Unfortunate injuries / bad deals (slightly), unfortunate injures / bad deals, managering.... I can't come up with an excusable reason for your third point.