LOL. Are you kidding me? Young's number in the 2 games against Georgia reminds me of Watson against Alabama in the 2 - Nat.Champ. games. Maye didn't play poorly? Look at his game against Georgia Tech....LOL. Hell, look at his last 3 games. Those are not I can carry my team numbers. Look at Young's and Williams' numbers. They CARRIED their team against GOOD teams. Williams was on one leg against Utah...and did all he could, but the USC defense was trash.
Did I call you a name? One receiver doesn’t make up for the overwhelming talent gap between Bama and USC/NC. Seems like you can’t take any opposing opinion without getting upset.
Im not upset. With every post your opinions prove to be less and less objective and not supportable by any fact. I don’t hold Williams or Maye losing games against them because they can’t play defense, but when we’re looking at offense which they are responsible for it’s fair to judge everything. The fact is that Maye had a better receiving Corp this year than Young and still struggled offensively in multiple games against worse defenses. So from an objective standpoint his numbers are not as good and that’s fact. He has another year to improve or regress, but so far both Young and Williams have performed better than Maye and that’s not disputable. If all that mattered were physical traits, we should be picking Anthony Richardson number 1 and call it a day because he’s faster and has a stronger arm than Drake Maye.
It is absolutely disputable. Young did not outperform Maye in any capacity. And again, one receiver doesn’t make up for the massive discrepancy in depth at receiver, TE and Oline. You can’t even be objective whatsoever. That’s apparent. Maye is the superior prospect, physically and performance. The dude hasn’t played a down of college football until this year. He’s a stud. Williams is a stud. Young is a stud, just not on the level of the other two.
And? All of that was absolute fact after last season. Only an idiot would think different. Lance is still worse than Mills. Fields is a running back. Lawrence is meh. Mills has regressed.
Maye wasn’t dogshit against Clemson. If you watched the game you would see he is the offense. They were way outmatched. The hypocrisy with you is ridiculous. You and Omihall say that Bama didn’t have anyone and Young carried them, yet they had two losses on a relatively weak schedule. Doesn’t make sense
No it wasn’t. Don’t lie to try and prove an incorrect point. Almost all of that was off-season and beginning of season. And……..as “bad” as Mills has been, Fields passing numbers aren’t much better and is still worse in their career.
Dude, did you miss it? Georgia Tech has one of the BEST defenses in the league. The allowed 400 yards a GAME to their opposition, only 187 yards to Maye. Then UNC played NC State with a 4th string QB.
